Transcript
k8TOjqVG6DY • "The Big Recession Is Coming" - Once In A Lifetime Opportunity To Build Wealth | Arthur Hayes
/home/itcorpmy/itcorp.my.id/harry/yt_channel/out/TomBilyeu/.shards/text-0001.zst#text/1082_k8TOjqVG6DY.txt
Kind: captions Language: en the crisis kicks off the money printing continues and I assume when you think about money Printing and analogy to use would be a rubber band that's being pulled farther and farther back and every failure releases tension because we those people they lose and we don't have to make them whole and there's no more printing there's it's not inflationary and every time we print more there's more tension more attention more attention um is that how you look at that you're waiting for the Domino the housing Mark or sorry the regional banking goes uh the the FED decides they're going to bail them out we pour a ton of money into this system uh and you're just waiting for that moment where there's too much tension like is do you see a um when you say a big disturbance happens do we just load up more tension on the rubber band but we're still who knows 10 20 years away from a real crisis or do you think it has to break and that's why we go into the a great depression style um problem so I think we've moved the crisis upstairs to the the the sovereign debt markets and so this crisis will be the buyers refuse to buy long-end bonds of a particular government because we're all every government's in the same sort of position different things can set it off but again Global debt to GDP is 360% why on Earth would I as an investor own a long-end bond when I know that there's nobody getting born and there's not going to be an energy productivity miracle there's just no way for me to get paid back in a real dollar a real Yen a real renb uh at a rate that's affordable for the government for me to make money over time so then why own these bonds I'm perfectly happy to sit in like overnight you know fed deposits or um short end bonds of a particular company because I know I can just sell those pretty quickly and not suffer any sort of capital loss but if I'm forced to sell a 10-year treasury or or you know a 10year Chinese Bond or a Japanese Government Bond 10 30 20 years because rates have gone up I'm going to suffer a massive Capital loss so then why even own that stuff and if nobody wants to own the long end on the Government Bond Market the rates will go up a lot and then the response is some form of either closing down the banking system so making sure that depositors cannot f to other asset classes and then forcing deposits to buy um government bonds uh this is called fiscal dominance is is a theory or it's called the next thing is called yield curve control where the the Central Bank says okay we know you all want to leave this market so we're going to fix the price at a particular level whatever is politically expedient whatever is Affordable for the government we're going to Telegraph this and we're going to expand our balance sheet INF ly to make sure that the Rat St out that level so in Japan the bank of Japan is doing this been doing this for almost a decade where they say they determine a band of the yield and they say if the if the yield gets um to a certain level we will go into the market and buy bonds by printing money to make sure the yields don't go up the United States did this back in the late 40s and early 50s to pay back the the debt from World War II by capping long end treasury rates 10 year rates at 10 2 and a half% the Fed was expand its balance sheet to make sure the rate is that level so if we get a Revolt from large asset holders who say I don't want to own these long bonds because I know mathematically there's no way for me to make money um in a real basis I would rather own stocks I would rather own crypto I'd rather own oil field I'd rather own gold whatever it is then the only response is to move to the end game which is okay we fix the yield and we just print money until uh as long as it's it's required to keep the yield at that level and once you've gone to yield curve control in or something similar in in the US um it's already in Japan um something might happen similarly in China and other places then the question is okay can the authorities keep the money inside their banking systems or are there ways for us the people to get our money outside of the system so that on a real basis we're able to maintain our energy purchasing power and that becomes the real fulcrum of the crisis because because if if all the money is sitting in the banking system and it can't leave which has been able to do prior to bitcoin and some of these other um blockchain based cryptocurrencies then they just tax us all and over time uh the government basically earns itself out of the of the situation yes there's High inflation um depending on how your company your country is structured maybe it's hyperinflation maybe it's just you know High inflation and some governments fall some governments stay the same but at the end of the day most The Government Can Survive but if we the people can get our money into a month a type of money or a type of asset that's outside of the government control outside of the banking system then the system collapses well that is uh that is a very unnerving thing said very calmly Mr Hayes uh so okay how give me give me like the odds here so if if Japan has been doing yield curve control for a while uh for a decade you said um I've been to Japan it's amazing so is there really a problem because it sounds bad but having experience if if my time in Tokyo is what yield curve control looks like it's not so bad so what am I missing why is that something to be very wary of so I think people have mistaken the fact that we've been able to print so much money and not have an adverse effect they're not looking at why what has changed in the global economy over the past um let's call it 20 years and what has changed is China China joined the WTO in 2000 and essentially became the workshop of the world and so you've lowered the cost of goods across every single sector because of China and they're willing to number one degrade their environment to capture market share and a lot of the dirty processings so rare Earths um different types of commodity refining um that the west and Japan are not willing to do um they have had a growth of young people willing to go into factory work and do these things at a very cheap wage um and that is it we don't have China anymore China number one is dying just like everybody else their population is like forecast to be half of what it is by the you know by the end of the century China the population in China has also decided that they do not want to live in a small field Factory and they have told their government to prioritize um protecting the environment which basically means that China does no longer want to essentially pollute itself so that America Western Europe and you know Japan and Korea don't have to right so we're going to make these things more expensive um and so there is no more big country that's going to join and essentially degrade themselves so that the rest of the world the rest of the very developed and Rich world can enjoy a higher standard of living all the while they're printing a bunch of money so there is no more that's this not going to happen again and so I think that's what people miss about why we were able to print all this money over the last 20 years and not really have any sort of adverse effects um that's just not going to happen anymore well so I'll ask maybe the UNC question but the obvious question so India is still growing um is there because the the thing that I'm dancing around is being right about the concepts but getting the timing wrong is the same is being wrong and so what I don't want to do is um get myself all worked up that you know the sky falling this is all going to be bad uh I need to get my money out of the banking system I don't want the government to close the exits I don't want them to force me to buy things uh I want to maintain my financial autonomy I want to maintain my freedom I want to come and go where I want uh and certainly there are many many many horror stories throughout time of governments doing that um and if there is a way to keep this party going again I'll just use Japan as an example you know my whole life I've heard Japan is in stag flation but again being in Japan it's it's beautiful and lovely and there are wonderful restaurants and exceptional people and for me as a Storyteller some of my favorite storytelling comes out of Japan like there just doesn't seem to be look I've never lived there but there doesn't seem to be downsides it's not like I'm like oh my God I would never want to be in Japan I'm like this [ __ ] place is amazing um so I hear your point about China and China the just booming growth and the amount of things that we were all able to reap the benefits of is as the you know developed World a little bit ahead of them uh we were able to reap the benefits of their transition period which is just astonishing to have been cognizant while it was happening was really something magnificent and look I was far removed but still had a sense of how extraordinary their growth was um are we not poised to see the same thing in India so on the Japan thing because this is called the the Widowmaker trade the oh my God Japan's dying oh my God Deb to GDP just only goes in one direction oh my God the boj's balance sheet is is going through the roof so Japan is essentially just like China Japan is a more successful version of China they both have run the exact same industrial Playbook Japan had two nuclear bombs dropped on it by the United States um and the US essentially baited a colony for a bit uh and so what did Japan do they reoriented reoriented themselves to making [ __ ] for America and essentially the Japanese government and the large companies made essentially a PCT which said okay we're going to give all the people jobs for life you work really hard for the nation of Japan to make things to you know the grow the prosperity of the country and but you're not going to keep all of the productivity gains right that difference uh is going to go essentially to these large companies and they're going to reinvest that profit back into the United States and Western Europe essentially so if you look at Japan as a country they're one of the richest countries in the world on a net investment P um portfolio perspective they've got like one or two trillion dollars worth of assets what are those assets the those are that's essentially the productivity gains of their people over you know since World War II so Japan has this buffer of money that can cushion themselves they owe the money to themselves it's not as if um the the money is owed to you know the the foreigners out there you really can't buy Japanese debt in in large quantities so yes ja Japan is a unique situation where number one they they have a lot of assets um number two their banking system is relatively closed right it's not as if Saudi Arabia can go in there and buy a billion you know a trillion dollars with the Japanese bonds they just won't let them do it right because they don't want the the the situation that the United States is in where essentially Capital holders determine the the policy of of the nation and and number three Japan has been you know very fortunate to use the labor of China and Southeast Asia to reduce the cost of Labor if you look at the major Japanese trading houses and manufacturers and if you go around southeast Asia you see there's a lot of Japanese companies who have factories in all these countries employing all this labor that's very cheap versus the very expensive J labor in in Japan Japan's a very special case but again all that's running out because the countries that did not benefit from the last 80 years are like well why am I the the donkey for Japan to make a lot of money or the United States where Europe I want High wages I want to live in the Hollywood movie I want more energy consumption I'm not going to sell my resources to these other countries um cheaply anymore and so inflation in Japan is actually for the first time Rising it's at I don't know four or five% highs in 40 years the isahi for the first time in 30 years rais beer prices right so the problem is when inflation shows up and so when you exhaust a cheap labor when you exhaust a cheap energy when you sell on all of your trillions of dollars of assets and inflation remains in a world where the United States is not able to dictate the flows of energy unilaterally then your special circumstance you know since the collapse of your Equity market and property Market since the late 80s is no longer valid and so I think people are making a mistake by not understanding why Japan is successful to say oh if Japan did it they they can be successful let's take a look at the United States the United States owes the world something around $1 to2 trillion do the United United States runs a current account deficit and a budget deficit um so it's the completely different financial situation than Japan the United States foreigners own a lot of the debt the United States relies on the foreigners to buy the debt to fund itself at affordable levels it's a completely opposite situation of Japan so saying that Japan did it and it's okay it can work in the United States misses the differences fundamentally between the two um the two situations now want to like you know don't freak out and go you know move all your money into gold or what or something and you know suffer some Capital losses my you know how I structure my portfolio is to benefit from both situations I have high nominal rates right now right I know on a real basis I'm losing money but thankfully um as a percentage of my uh my net worth the amount of money I consume on food and energy is very low so even if I have a 5% rate and it's still a negative real gate on the amount of capital that I have I'm still making more than I need to sustain myself so keep some money in cash put it in a money market fund you're making five six% and take whatever you can afford a small amount and put it in something that's going to benefit if money printing resumes that could be Nvidia stock it could be Bitcoin it could be um productive Farmland whatever you want to have a barb you want to make sure that in the event that the the money starts getting printed I can easily move on out of my short-term you know money market fund government bonds into the risky stuff for the fixed Supply and zoom up that way or if nothing happens I'm still earning money I'm stting earning yield over here on my my uh my treasuries or whatever short-term government bonds I can fund some of my my expenses and I I run a positive carry trade meaning I've structured my portfolio such that if [ __ ] really [ __ ] up I'm going to make so much money on on the on in that situation but as long as not it's very calm I'm still covering day-to-day expenses and so you want to have a a an optionality portfolio that costs you little to nothing if not makes you money over time if you're able to construct that then again timing doesn't matter because you're not paying for time if you're selling a bunch of stuff and you've got everything in the risky bucket yes I would agree with you then you're like well when is it going to happen it didn't happen last month and I'm down I'm down such percent or I needed to buy you know go to the hospital because I had an e injury and I had to sell down some of my this portfolio that I'm like betting on this collapse and that was financially ruinous right so it's all about trying to construct this portfolio where the cost of waiting is zero to making money versus you know it's costing me money the longer this takes to happen Okay so I want to go a little bit deeper um into exactly how you structure your portfolio from so I heard the we're going to do a barbell strategy we want to make sure that we can move one way or the other depending on what's going on um as something starts to pop off but you said uh risky stuff with a fixed Supply so hiding in that are are what I'll call two philosophical principles risky stuff I'm guessing you mean High volatility and so explaining to people why volatility is a feature and not a bug I think may be surprising to somebody and then why a fixed Supply so again we want to make the we want to basically participate in the upside to the maximum we can um right so we want the high volatile stuff we want the crypto we want the the tech stocks right um but on when stuff doesn't happen then we want our breaks so like a car right you want to go as fast as you can on the straightaway when you are racing and you want the best brakes possible so you can take those corners and and not get wrecked right so the braks are cash short-term cash instruments that are earning yield that's that's paying you your grocery bill you're you're filling up your car tank whatever it is that you need to do you want to be making sure you can cover those expenses with some cash in the bank or in a money market fund or something like that and hire a yielding instrument so you can pay some of those expenses so that when shit's ready to go oh I'm over here I'm ready to make as much money as possible when they're printing money I'm not in this safe boring thing because this situ doesn't happen there's not very many straightaways right I need to make as much money as I can when the making money is good and then put the brakes back on right as if you were a race car driver that's kind of how I want to think about it okay so knowing that these trades are excruciatingly difficult to pull off so for people that don't know you you manage your own money you've often said you find it intellectually stimulating it's fun uh I will ask the question that better be on everybody's mind so lifetime are you up or down up okay good so we know at at least your strategy has worked once uh that's very valuable so how do we make the volatility work for us because the obviously the best advice and and people laugh at this but I think they laugh at this at their own Peril because they don't understand why it's become the phrase Buy Low sell high now it got repeated so many times that it became funny because people think it's so self-evident but in reality it's the thing people never do they almost always buy high and sell low they buy High because it's hype it's moving they finally pay attention they ape in and then it starts trending down they panic and they sell as it's lower than when they bought it so um let's assume that they're going to be uh emotionally cognizant they're going to stay calm they're not going to make that mistake but how do they know which of the risky assets to do do how do they know how to do volatility well um it's personal preference right like obviously I'm in the crypto sphere I love crypto I understand it um the volatility doesn't scare me for some people they might you know that that's that's that's too much for me maybe I'm going to stick with NASDAQ tech stocks I understand that I get you know I understand why this particular company could do well you know I'm going to jump on the AI Tech it doesn't really matter what it is right but looking at whatever it is that you think is going to be your upside winner look at so hold on it it not only does it matter what it is it's the only thing that matters because if they bet wrong they either make no money or God forbid they lose a lot of money so the most important thing is not the upside it's the break the break is I own right now the break is I own cash and a five and a half six% yielding money Mar or wherever you are in the world whatever that is like shortterm government that's the break that's paying your bills that's you know paying your rent that's earning you a little bit of income right because at the end of the day you want this portfolio to make you money while you're wait so if to turn that into to turn it into a principle you're saying basically you're going to move into high volatility something that you have some reason to believe is going to do well but you should not be putting more into the high volatility than you can see go to absolutely zero you should have enough in the break category that even if all of that goes to zero that you're still going to be able to eat and fill your tank up exactly because you're going to know when to move into highall stuff fed Market panics everything's getting dumped fed comes in overnight says we are backstopping the financial system and we've created some alphabet letters that essentially mean print money right and it could be you know pick your different Central Bank and wherever you're from then you know okay cash is trash I was earning 6% overnight now it's zero I'm out of this and guess what you're not going to suffer any Capital loss versus if I were in some other type of instrument you need a liquid or whatever right so I can get out of this thing very easily and boom I maybe I had some already in my high volatility bucket but now I'm I'm fully out that high volatility bucket because I no longer earning anything on the cash so there's no why would I have anything in the other bucket I wouldn't because I I'm getting zero I'm getting nothing so I have to go into that because I have to find something that's going to maintain its purchasing power once the when the denominator of Fiat money expands infinitely so you'll know it'll be it's not as if like the S&P you know went up three times the instant that um Ben beri unveiled quantitative easing in 20 in March 2009 it took many many many years it's not like it's you have time this isn't like oh [ __ ] I gotta go you know sell this buy this and I miss it by a day and therefore goes my return for the next year no you're going to have time um it'll be very clearly communicated it's just are you listening to what they're saying if you want to have a solid strategy in place to grow your business you need to have a very clear and accurate picture of the business finances as your starting point but managing finances has historically been a tedious and timec consuming task that very few entrepreneurs want to make time for or even have time for now however you can revolutionize the way you manage business finances with QuickBooks the number one accounting software for small businesses bookkeeping with QuickBooks is easy with one place to track expenses and inventory organize and manage bills send invoices calculate tax and deductions and compare projects for profitability and with QuickBooks payroll you can streamline Payday track time manage HR and offer team benefits so discover why 88% of customers say QuickBooks helps their business be more successful and save yourself time by bundling bookkeeping and payroll just click the link below to get 50% off three months of QuickBooks payroll try it today if you run a small business and your goal is to stay competitive and grow effectively in 2024 then you need to make sure you have a killer CRM one that allows you to connect with your customers needs like never before HubSpot starter CRM Suite provides your small business with the essential tools education and support you need to grow efficiently attract new customers automate your Outreach save time and connect better with your customers with HubSpot the most powerful and easy to use customer relationship management software with integrated marketing sales and customer service tools you have everything you need to efficiently build your business in no time find out why over 200,000 customers from more than 130 countries trust HubSpot to bring their team tool and data together all in one place and that includes the impact the team by the way click the link below to try HubSpot for free today okay so that makes investing sound easier than I have uh experienced it to be so the way again saying very clearly nobody should take investing advice from me and I mean nobody I am still grappling to understand this stuff but when people do ask me hey Tom with your limit an understanding of investing what do you advise that I do my thing is always uh you're going to lose if you try to trade so don't try to trade meaning actively like I'm in there oh I got just right and I'm trading in the morning and in the afternoon like you're going to lose guaranteed uh what I would tell them to do is pick the most Diversified bundle of whatever whatever uh so whether that's the S&P or you said AI grow stocks I don't know if You' consider that high volatility uh but something that where it spreads your risk risk that is commensurate with the amount of knowledge that you have if you don't have a lot of knowledge in it then I would go very Broad and I would be very careful and I'd be trying to get as close to rayo's all weather fund as humanly possible something that's going to perform four or five% no matter what happens um that's when you're ignorant like me that is the the thing that I would push people towards um do you agree with that when people don't know and do you agree if you're going to get into something that's high volatility you should only do it in an area that you understand I think you need to Define your time span I think a lot of people think they're like wow I see this person on TV or Tik Tok or Instagram or whatever and they went from Zero to Hero and you know five trading days and made all this money so I should do the same thing like if you're not willing to dedicate 247 of Your Life Energy looking at a screen then you should not be trading on on short time frames so what does that mean don't use leverage um don't open up the the the the the options trading account or the Futures Trading account if you're not willing to put in the work to sit there and trade now obviously I have a large ownership in a Futures exchange I'm not saying don't use my product I'm saying if you are going to be a day trader then be a day trader and dedicate yourself to doing it don't work a day job think you're going to come home at night for two hours and just trade yourself into you know quitting your job right it's it's a profession it's a dedication you can do it but be willing to put in the work to do it if you're not willing to put in the work to do it then you know broad-based indices you know different things whatever you understand collectively okay I want to own stocks I don't really know what okay well my country has a particular Index right everyone's gonna be a lot of people going to be on this buying the same thing it's a question of taking that index and combining it with the breaks that's the the point to be able to both participate in the general rise in in asset prices but not care when it happens and if you can construct that port pfolio then you can sit at home and you know not worry about it not worry about it meaning you need to have patience for when the moment is actually right and if you've deployed Capital into long-term things uh you're not going to be able to take advantage of the moment when it comes or if youve if you've basically thought you're going to day trade yourself out of this and you're staring at the screen all day and you're not willing to put in the work to actually be a good day trader then youve you've squandered your opportunity versus saying okay I don't know when the timing is going to be but I know that I have thank to these relatively higher interest rates I have the ability to both earn some income on my excess cash and play a small amount of cash into highly what I what I believe is highly volatile things whatever that is for you and and that can allow you to sit there and patiently wait for the inevitable math to catch up with the bad politics okay so let's run through what you said is your uh likely scenario that 3 to six months something bad is going to happen uh it's going to cause a ton of money printing but I'm guessing in the money printing is when you're saying we're going to have this sort of jubilant moment uh where everybody is feeling flush and um I forget the you said it's G to be some huge moment I I forget how big you were saying but it's really going to be wonderful and then it's all going to lead to uh something like the Great Depression um how do we ride that wave and that crash so that we do well in both moments when the money printing starts we want to go to High volatility that's the play yeah so my my my sort of mental mind cap now is I think the the biggest Trend in so you always want to own the new tech thing in in the in the Bunty bing bull market so if you look over history the new tech thing it's been railroads it's been radios it's been computers it's been the internet right every single money printing cycle has a new technology that's going to fundamentally alter this modern civilization that we've had since the Industrial Revolution in the mid 19th century and therefore we all need to be in that because the way we exist as humans is going to fundamentally change and yes that's true in a longer term perspective however there's a Mania that happens so the mania this time around is going to be AI right chat GPT has been the fastest growing technology adoption ever in human history went from I don't know Z to 100 million years or in however many days it was it's fastest ever uh so we are all in on AI and you can look at Nvidia and some of these other you know AI related stocks and they do not give two [ __ ] about this banking crisis about the the debt overhang the population issues they're going straight to the roof right because everyone's like okay I know AI on a on a long-term basis fast forward today is going to completely change what it means to be human what the human economy is or isn't and I want to own the next Google Facebook Amazon Alibaba bite dance right I want to be in that company and so I'm going to start trying to find anything that's related to Ai and pumping money into it so on one hand we have the most amount of money that's ever going to be printed in human history to try to save the global Keynesian bond market of all these governments and we have the newest technology that has the fastest adoption in ever in history of a technology we're going to combine those two we're going to get the biggest Tech boom Mania that we've ever seen and it's going to be predicated on anything related to Ai and artificial intelligence so for me personally I have a portion of my portfolio that is predicated on AI I actually am one of the largest shareholders in one of the largest sexy manufacturers in the US that has robotic sex dolls um and so I did not see that coming um the I think we actually plan on going public at some point so that stock that company I think is do very well in this boom on the crypto side of things I've been making the case that um artificial intelligent economic agents inherently need decentralization and therefore they should be using Bitcoin for money they should be using ethereum for um smart contracts and governance and Dows and they should be using filecoin for decentralized storage I own all three whether it's mining companies and filecoin fcoin itself lots of ethereum I have my family office we're investing in decentralized architecture technology that's going to power the growth and decentralization in the future and obviously have you know I have a lot of Bitcoin right so I'm all in on number one AI in the traditional sense AI Robotics and I'm all in on the intersection of AI and crypto on the technology front because this is the Mania that is going to Captivate investors to take that money and to funnel it somewhere because they're not going to be buying companies like General Motors I mean maybe it'll go up but that's not going to be where the the Zeitgeist of a world is it's what is AI the governments are printing all this money it's got to go somewhere it's going to go predominantly in my opinion to AI listed companies Venture Capital funds doing AI investment and so it's going to be absolutely insane because we're combining the most money amount of money printed in human history with the most destructive piece of technology to what it is it means to actually be human and interact in this universe and so it's going to create fantasies of growth that will never happen in the time frame that they say it is but we're going to believe it as a collective investment public which is going to drive that so that's my super volatile um segment that I want to participate in um and then on sort of the the the boring side I will continue to move money from the high interest earning you know money market funds and stuff as rates start to come down but I'm not going to do it beforehand I'm gonna wait for them to tell me uh and usually unfortunately before right after the fed or any other Central Bank is printing money there's usually some sort of financial crash because the reason they're printing money is something bad happened so it's not as if they start printing money and things just keep going up further things usually went down a lot something happened they say oh [ __ ] we need to print money they print the money then things go they they retake that level and then they go higher than that so it's a mistake to think that just because you're investing now yes if you have long enough time frame you should make money if they print enough of it however it's the p is very path dependent so instead of trying to time the market just wait for them to tell you about it they're G to tell you but why not just earn 6% of your money market fund just chilling so I'm not trying to time when it's going to happen I have a mental model I'm getting prepared I'm making sure that we're ready to make investments and identifying the things that I think are going to do very well from a macro perspective and a thematic perspective in terms of where I think the investment public is going going to focus on but I cannot predict the timing and nor do I want to lose money because I try to be too cute and predict when you know something's going to happen where exactly it's going to happen in the financial system and so when you say that they're going to tell you meaning we're going to print money we're raising rates we're lowering rates whatever the case may be yeah they're gonna they're gonna come out say oh because something happened in the financial system we have now lower rates to this we've introduced that program uh whatever it is right it's very transparent regardless of whether it's the Federal Reserve it's the pboc it's the European Central Bank it's the bank of Japan Bank of England they're going to tell you exactly what it is because what do they want you to do the Market's already fallen they want you the investing public to gain confidence to go and buy stuff so they need be very clear about what they're doing uh and the question is whether or not you believe them or you're just going to say no no no I'm just going to stay in this very very safe thing it's fine but on on a a real basis you're probably not going to make the money you would like to make before we get you know Judgment Day when things go down a lot okay so if we know that the market prices in the things that it already knows um you have to be betting against the consensus and being right so what would a well-intentioned person who disagrees with you say to what you're saying right now because if it really was that easy everybody watching this video would just do that and they'd make out like Bandits but of course it won't play out like that the consensus says that we're going to have a a a soft Landing that um these these few men mostly men very few women have somehow Divine the business cycle and thus can print just enough money and raise rates just enough and the inflation rate of the world is going to come down just to their level of 2% and the employment is going to stay the same and we're just going to go along and be nice and happy right that's the consensus that these guys know exactly what they're doing and they got it so which means you don't need you don't need to sell your stocks you don't need to sell your bonds you don't need you just just sit tight and keep adding more because there's not going to be any Financial disturbance because they have it right and inflation is going to Trend down right to their level exactly at 2% and it's going to be amazing that's the consensus so if you don't believe that then you believe something on either extr is gonna happen either rates going to go up really really high or some Financial disturbance is going to happen because they keep raising rates and force them to go right back down to zero and so my thesis is that when you have 360% Global debt to GDP you no longer have situations where things happen in a calm fashion you go to the extremes very quickly and so to think that all of a sudden you know less than 100 people are able to determine how this global economy is going to somehow soft land after printing the most money that we've ever printed in human history and gone from 5,000 year low of interest rates Rising the fastest Pace ever um in in financial markets then you're you know that's a bet I'm not willing to take do you know chamath poopaa yes I know chof okay I could be misquoting but I'm almost certain this is correct that he he was saying that you know people make such a big deal out of this 130% debt to GDP but he it's a big nothing Burger it doesn't really matter there's no law of physics that says that we can't go over it so even though historically uh that that's been a sign that has led to collapse given the modern economic theory and I'm so this is how I remember it oh God forgive me jth if I'm way off um but that that was my takeaway um so other than it's very compelling to me that we have all the historical examples that say every time that we do this it it leads to collapse but what do you if you were to take his stance for a second um can you see how maybe it is Poss possible that we get the soft Landing that they do get it right that that isn't some magic you know thing like the speed of light it can be crossed and people can still come back from it um and I think you would say that well I'm just gonna I'm gonna listen to what they say anyway I'm not going to make a move until I actually see it happening um yeah get could he be right so I would say we're investing is a game of probabilities and expected values so if chatha is saying okay there's been other examples where this has not been the case but this is going to be the one example where the markets just keep grinding a bit higher okay then you're taking a this is this time is different mental and every single time there's been a this time is different whatever aspect of the financial markets right the problem is you're not just getting you're not getting paid enough for this time is different this time is different means um S&P goes up I don't know four five% right I'm making 6% sitting my money in cash so why bet on this time is different if I can earn the majority of the excess return of Stocks by literally just putting my money in a money market fund and I have no risk the Federal Reserve is going to pay me that money why take the risk um this time is different because usually it's not different it's the same as every other time but there so I'm not getting paid enough to be this time is different that the only way to get paid enough is to add more leverage which increases your risk I'd rather take okay well the everyone believes this time is different therefore I'm not getting paid enough for it but the other alternative which is it's the same as it's always been but I get paid a lot more money to be in that camp I want to go there and on an expected value basis I'm going to make more money over time why not if you believe in shath just put your money in a money market fund don't buy any stocks why would like the S&P part from you know Nvidia and Facebook and Google and those seven big stocks has not beaten return on cash so either put your money in cash and go in AI stocks and believe this time is different or just put your money in a money market fund there there's no point to take the risk on the General market for this time is different because it's never different it's always been you know this time is different gets clobbered other than the AI High volatility stuff do you have anything deployed in the stock market right now uh uranium so I believe that we finally going to get our our [ __ ] together and somehow believe in nuclear and there's been vast underinvestment in uh uranium refining capacity and as the world moves to nuclear and maybe the the West decides that they want to be dumb and not do it fine but China's going nuclear India's going nuclear Saudi Arabia is going nuclear the rest of the world's going nuclear um and they just not enough refined yellow cake to go around so um you know Uranian mining companies and certain jurisdictions are going to do very well and um I'm I'm a large well not large it's by largest Equity position is um kamiko mining ccj uh it's up I don't know 80% this year uh so um that's something that I I believe in as a longer term Energy play okay so understanding now then the way that you're deployed I want to talk about Euphoria so I never experienced what Euphoria at the like Humanity level looked like until uh the 2021 2020 2021 crypto uh r it it was really fascinating to watch it it was great and it felt a certain way so I certainly know now what to look out for in The Ether um how how do you think about as a disciplined investor how do you think about Euphoria I know you're planning it into the AI like hey I know people are going to get their stimulus checks or you know the bailout however we want to categorize it uh they're going to put it into whatever is the hype thing of the moment you're expecting that to be AI um how do you know because I'm assuming you're going to get in probably not try to time the top perfectly but you're going to get in you're going to get some level of gain and then you're going to come back out I would assume if we're talking about Euphoria because Euphoria is I would say quite irrational and we know when that clicks over I would now uh be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful my now honed Instinct for that would kick in so I think Euphoria in my perspective is the the willing to invest in eLiquid things that have a beautiful long-term future so the problem with AI is that to get liquidity in my cycle time which is 2026 time frame you need to have been investing three four five years ago right because it takes if you're talking about equities takes five to seven years to go IPO for a company so if you're putting money into a series a startup today you're not going to see any liquidity until 20 30 you know time frame well after the ball Market even though on paper your thing might be up you can't actually sell it um because it's not it's not liquid now obviously I do a lot of um cryptographic token investing uh and stuff again if I'm signing a ter to you today due to lockups and whatnot I'm not getting my tokens until maybe 2026 2027 which might be a little bit too late for me on on the cycle Ty perspective so to the extent that I can I want to participate in my theme which is a in crypto in a way where I have liquidity by 2025 and 2026 so that when I get the feeling and you're going to see something I don't know what that something is whether it's just something that looks mispriced like I don't know um FTX has Tom Brady and a basketball stadium right it's this exchange that never existed two years ago now now has you know has our logo on top of in Miami and you know Tom Brady one some some would say the biggest American football player ever is now stumping for them on on TV that looks about strange right there's going to be something that looks a bit strange that's going to tickle your mind you like huh that doesn't make any sense maybe we've gone too far when you get that sense you want to be able to go to your portfolio and liquidate things now the Euphoria is that I believe that you know AI can be such a transformative thing that I'm willing to give somebody some money and not see it for a very very long time and not be able to to liquidate it at all and there therefore you're going to get caught off sides when the market all of a sudden goes okay well show me the growth show me how you're going to generate enough earnings to pay me back 100 times earnings Nvidia show me all the people willing to pay real money for these AI Solutions show me how your startup has any defensibility against open AI or Bard or any of these other um large um initiatives that could essentially just you know dis intermediate your little plugin on top of their large language models show me the money when the market starts saying that and you can't liquidate you're wrecked um because then the market is going to start asking the question where's the revenue where are the users U or where are the users that are actually willing to pay real money for for the product and that's usually the end of that particular bull market and things just start falling to bed because there's just no liquidity and people just sell what they can and so and the game is up now obviously out of the wreckage comes your Amazon was down 90 something per from high in 2000 to 2002 or whatever it was and then Rockets up multiples of what it was worth but the majority of us are not going to be able to find the Amazon we're going to be finding the pets.com um and so uh that's the game so it's trying to try to invest in the theme and the liquid Vehicles available and not getting to caught up in the hype and putting your money into eLiquid things that you can't sell when the mood turns we are at the culmin of the post World War II period we've we've we've had four generations since then so all the people who fought in the War pretty much dead so we've lost that that knowledge that reticence to ever do something stupid and terrible like a total World War ever again now we have people around the world who are celebrating these leaders who are bombing indiscriminate civilians because it you know solves their particular issue whatever that is because we don't have this institutional knowledge else is dead who would participated won World War II so and we also have a a situation where you know the United States did very well out of War War II and created a whole global system that to preserve their hegemony and now that's coming undone uh and you know when top dog is getting challenged by the dogs at the bottom there's always conflict and so we're at that point in time we have no institutional memory of how bad war is and we have a preeminent power that's being challenged by others who was going to resort to violence to preserve their position I think we are at this situation that has happened in the past many times empires have come and gone but now we have for the first time in human history a an ability to save in a currency Bitcoin and the cryptocurrency situation in general that is globally owned by everyone and so the people own a new type of money it's people around the world can still sell their Fiat whatever and buy Bitcoin it's not blocked or banned in most places yet and so you're able to move wealth between this analog system that we've had for thousands of years into a new way of socially creating Financial wealth the financial system uh a new type of money this sort of this sort of situation is never going to happen again because we have all these Fiat assets that are being depreciated and everyone knows it's happening and now we have this little small door called Bitcoin and people are starting to go through the small door and that's why the Bitcoin price is up I don't know 50% or 60% this year already as now we have the institutional investors saying yeah I understand this game is rigged I helped rig the game now I have a product where I can get out of this mess that I created get me the [ __ ] out of government bonds I want some of this Bitcoin too so now everyone's competing to get in this little door and that's why the price is going up so this is a once in a-lifetime opportunity we have a system reset and we have a way to preserve wealth in the old system and bring it into the new system and that's what crypto is all right that's powerful so if we think of crypto as the arc that we can all get on before the rain comes uh the catch is that you've got all kinds of different cryptocurrencies all kinds of different thesis about which one we should be getting into um what's your take how do you break down the world of crypto so Bitcoin is the reserve currency if you will of crypto it's the ultrasound money it's it's crypto money it's and it's proven that's that's what it cares about the community of Bitcoin cares about security and um the IM immutability of the Bitcoin blockchain and it wants to make it the soundest crypto money so if you're thinking about okay I don't know anything else about crypto but I kind of believe in this whole inflation and changing Global relations story then just buy Bitcoin right it's got the largest market cap um it's very conservative with the types of things that are added to the the network because everyone wants to make sure that Bitcoin is always the hardest money so the experimentation is much lower on bitcoin than other uh other networks um next you go to well okay can we build a new Financial system within crypto that's decentralized Finance defi um and ethereum in my in my worldview is the the best decentralized computer that has been built uh thus far and so if you think okay I think we need a new Financial system that's based on these crypto know crypto assets that's the centralized that's transparent blah blah blah then ethereum uh is where it's at now once you get past those two things I'd say most other things than crypto are either some sort of application that rides on top of ethereum or a decentralized like computer another blockchain trying to disrupt either being the best money or the best decentralized computer and then you sort of have to get into the Weeds on understanding what it is these Protocols are are trying to do so for those who just want to like close their eyes and buy something that's crypto safe not saying that's you know there's no risk here I would say Bitcoin and ethereum are where you should start your journey and once you say okay maybe there's some things I think these protocols could do better or I've been hearing some things about these exciting new very smart people building something then you start going down the rabit hole of of other coins that do other things and obviously have more risk because they're experimenting more what do you advise people around volatility I think one of the things that draws people to crypto specifically is the volatility I'm actually very curious to see what happens to um cultural energy around crypto once it's the the tried and true thing volatility is your friend the reason why you're even thinking about crypto is because the price went up a lot and you heard about it so you want volatility the entire trafi traditional government apparatus is trying to do something unnatural which is remove volatility from the system entropy is always increasing it is unnatural to try to suppress volatility think about it like your lawn if you have one at your house right entropy says the grass keeps growing because that's what the grass does what do you try to do you spend energy to cut the grass because you want it to look a certain way a certain nonvolatile Pleasant way but it's unnatural if you don't have the energy to cut the grass the Grass Grows and the grass will grow long after you're gone because you can only do this so long and that's the same thing governments and central banks and banking systems are doing they're trying to squash volatility we don't want volatility and they're try to convince you that it's safe but there is no such thing as safe there's chaos in the universe it's always increasing they're doing the unnatural Thing by trying to remove it and then at certain points they can't do it anymore and then there's an explosion somewhere whether it's a war whether it's a financial crisis so embrace the volatility this is the nature of the universe and that's why Bitcoin and crypto is a good thing because there is none of this manipulation it goes up it goes down but it's a TR reflection of what the universe is so I think volatility is a good thing obviously that means if you use leverage be very judicious about it if you're a leverage if leverage trading is your thing that better be your full-time job like you better eat breathe and sleep the thing that you're trading because that's the only way that you're going to survive thinking that you're going to get home from work put on some highly leveraged crypto trade and just trade for a few hours and then go to sleep you will lose all your money okay volatility as a good thing do you think that crypto will lose some of its um its potency its C cultural energy when the volatility begins dying down or will like in a given cycle the way that this traditionally goes is uh you've got Bitcoin which has massive volatility but is less Vol volatile than some of the what people lovingly call shitcoins um so people tend to go down the curve so they'll start with Bitcoin they'll ride that up as that begins to stabilize and chop sideways then they're going to go to the next volatile if that crashes or whatever they go to the next the next the next constantly chasing volatility um will that forever be people will just keep introducing new and highly volatile things or will it become more like gold where it's it's a far more stable entity well Bitcoin has you law of large numbers the larger it gets the less volatile it become um and as you mentioned right for people who are saying I want to make big gains in a short period of time Bitcoin might not do it for them they say well I need the next new new new thing and so they start trading whatever the new shiny Bobble is that's being sold out there in in crypto there's nothing wrong with that just recognize what you're trying to do if you're saying I want to save in a ultrasound money then yes so volatility is not a good or bad thing for Bitcoin it's it will go down over time as the asset class gets bigger if you're saying I need the volatility I'm a professional Trader this is what I'm here for then there will always be a new thing to trade because the great thing about crypto is it's this the only free market left where humans are expressing themselves and whatever is we think is valuable there's no manipulating force with you know an unlimited bag of fiat currency that's telling us what is a good and or bad investment and so there will always be volatile things within the crypto ecosystem so long as there's human beings trading it and I guess we other machines too soon these AI operators uh in the ecosystem it's really interesting so I want to get to the essence of um what crypto is I want to get to the essence of whatk are why people play them so I I really want to be the contribution that I make to um I mean anything that I do quite frankly is helping people get to the essence of it to think from first principles to build a thesis uh even though ultimately I think that only the simple spreads I do want people to be able to understand the the nature of this do do you see markets as gambling like are they gambling at their very nature i' move it even more fundamental we are gamblers everyone all the time constantly because we don't know what the future holds um so let's take an example and I wrote this in a previous essay so imagine you're going to there's a building you walk outside the building you can either take the stairs or take an elevator um so the stair taking the stairs using your own feet walking up is safer than the mechanical thing which is is an elevator but walking up the stairs takes more energy than riding up the elevator so what do you do well your brain you know whether you're conscious of it or not is constantly evaluating the probability that if I do one of these things will there will there be harm that comes to me and is the probability of that harm outweighed by the gain whether it's time or energy by using one or the other modes of transportation and so you're gambling know what do you know if this elevator is going to break down and fall 30 flights in an instant no but you believe that there's been a um credible engineer that's designed this piece of technology that there's a government building codes that govern how it's been installed and how it's been maintained so the risk of me taking this elevator even though I don't know if it's going to fail when I get on it is very very low therefore I will take the elevator because it's faster and less energy spent than walking up the stairs to the top of the building right so we gamble all day every day because the future is unknown so for people that say that oh markets are bad because it's gambling no your whole life is a gamble you do not know what's going to happen one moment to the next you are constantly assigning a probability to the Future and that's what the market is the market is for a particular thing what does the crowd say the probability of the future of this company building this product making this money or this asset being wor worth whatever it's worth in the future what does the crowd think that's what the market is telling us and the market gives us great signals as to what the crowd actually thinks because we're putting our money on the line and what is money money is Just Energy and our time in an abstracted form that's why money is the most important thing in any society because if you degrade the value of money you degrade someone's time and their effort and their energy and it's you know a front to human dignity if you grade the value of the money that they earn by doing work to you know earn a living pay for food blah blah blah right so markets are gambling but your entire existence is a gamble as well so I don't think there's a problem with that okay this is uh really interesting and it goes back to what I was talking about with um the ability to save from where I'm sitting feels like it should be a human right uh so okay let me just go back and recap what you said money is energy and time and abstracted form so uh you go to work and some you do a thing that the world says that they value which is why somebody's willing to pay you for that because they're able to create a thing that they sell to somebody so you spend energy and time creating a thing that people want to buy now what that allows you to do is proof of work so you have this unit of money that you've exchanged for your labor now when you are putting that into a system where they can socialized losses so H this is it drives me crazy how complicated this all is but let me just walk everybody through what ends up happening in the current Keynesian economic model that we have which uh I'll give a brief summation of Keynesian economics if you see that I've gone wrong in any way please jump in uh Keynesian economics is basically hey uh the market left to its natural devices is going to swing wildly there are going to be massive upsides there are going to be massive downsides and if you if you get to one of the moments where the economy is not able to progress forward part of the reason it may not be progressing forward and this was the break from the classical model is that people are just poor and so if you stimulate money into the system now you can get the economy moving again and so you flatten the curves both on the upside and the downside so you're squeezing the volatility by going back to your mowing the lawn analogy you're injecting energy into the system the the government is putting this new money which they're making up out of thin air into the system in order to get people feeling like they have money again it is very much a a man-made manipulation of the system but this is essentially what we've been doing since the Great Depression so uh kees comes up with this idea in the Great Depression and he realizes hey wait a second there are people willing to work there are factories here that are not at capacity there are even people willing to buy and if they just had money then the economy would start moving again so hey make up money okay sounds amazing until you put it together with what you just said and the fact that this is socializing losses so all right something bad happens 1929 we have an economic collapse um people got into a bubble we just got into a bad situation for a whole host of reasons I won't go into it right now but anyway bad thing happens the government then says oh I'm going to print more money which is now taking that loss and spreading it across everybody that's what happens when you're printing money because there's no new Goods put into the system that anybody wants there's no new labor that has gone into the system there's only the artifact what should be the artifact of somebody's time and energy but it's not it's just made up and so that ends up diluting across everybody so you have individual losses with that are spread across everybody to the benefit of only people that hold assets so now you get this massive bifurcation so I'm very worried about the hollowing of the middle class and going back to what exactly creates this as far as I can tell is this it is this moment right here where you are socializing losses across everybody so the poor the middle class and the wealthy are all going to have their buying power reduced but only people that have assets are going to get wealthier and so what's crazy is if you look at the moment that we're living in right now you have a growth in the upper class so if you break lower middle upper you've growth in the upper and you've growth in the lower and only the middle class is going down now first I was like well that's kind of exciting you actually have more people going into the upper class than you have going into low lower class amazing right but as you Hollow that out you get just literal Division and warfare within a country all of that makes sense based on what you just said which is that money is your time and energy in an abstract form and it is an affront to human dignity when you begin messing with that system yes now laying all that out this this is why I am really unnerved by the moment that we're living in now and we'll I'll try to tie this all back to um crypto as the potential Arc that we're all going to get on as the the rain continues to fall but just today uh one of my employees came up to me and was like I'm finally seeing the data that backs up what I feel which is I just cannot get she didn't say American Dream but that was the punchline I can't afford to buy a house I see other people people making huge amounts of money and I'm not I'm not able to get ahead and on paper it seems like I'm making enough money but I just don't feel like I'm getting anywhere and so she isn't positive about the moment that she's in nor is she optimistic about the future because there there are these cues that people look to buying nice things having a nice car having a nice house feeling like you can afford children feeling like when you retire it's going to be travel and fancy rest and it isn't going to be me working until I'm 85 and you know super unhappy and so when you take that you take the anger you take the frustration you take the GameStop of it all again people yoloing in people I don't want to say following sort of culty ideas but like an idea will gain momentum and they just get on board with that momentum versus doing what you said get your spending under control figure out your risk appetite deploy that into um an asset class that you believe is matches your risk appetite and is going to go somewhere okay so there's been a demoralization of people they don't understand what it is but it's not to be too harsh but it's it's Keynesian economic it's the manipulation of the currency it's the massive inflation to deal with debt okay if all of that is true then it certainly explains this Great Migration from trafi over into crypto does all of that feel right or do you feel like I'm being unfair to the current economic situation the Keynesian economics maybe I don't understand it I mean the only wrinkle that I would say is that if the government is able to borrow money and build things of real economic value like okay in the 1950s Eisenhower did the in the United States President US President Eisenhower did the highway act right and the US built however many millions of kilometers of roads which lowered cost of Transportation you know had all this you basically had the explosion of mass Market stuff because you could ship things from coasta coast blah blah blah in China you had building of hydroelectric dams okay there was some environmental costs but it brought electricity to the countryside and so these are only projects that governments can can do because they have the ability to tax uh and spend on a on a aggregate level so I see the only cave is if you're able as a government to build these types of things that have a rate of return greater than the debt the implicit debt cost that you're hoting on the economy then those are good things to do the problem is that there there's there's a finite amount of projects like that uh the society that you're building these things in can only accept so much of this infrastructure spending the problem is that governments don't know when to stop they don't know they think everything's going to be like the highway act in the 1950s in the United States or building free gorg's Dam and China versus where it is today which is the buing they're building a lot of stuff that has no value because it'll never earn back its its return what are we building today well I mean I'm saying we as a global Society I don't know what politicians in the US are building in China or anywhere I'm just making of sort of a oblate statement of people I don't know there's Biden doing what's it the inflation reduction act or some sort of act that they're building stuff and all these government subsidies to build things whether it's electrification of the Grid or whatever right there's industrial policies for governments around the world saying we need to build whatever it is we think is valuable as a government sometimes that's rooted in Market signals other time it's just hey I want to give a a backhander to my boy in my uh in my district that's the problem there is a good there is good that can be done doing that but politicians abuse it and we're at the abusive stage of you know the initial gains of building some of these pieces of public infrastructure now we're just doing stupid [ __ ] Ray alio talks a lot about debt cycles and the inevitability of how this just Loops over and over um is all of this inevitable and do you think that the migration to cryptocurrency will be complete and we'll never be back in a system like this again or do you think these systems will coexist so it's definitely not inevitable uh the great example is what's happened down in Argentina so the policy of Argentina is if you've never been it's a beautiful country I [ __ ] love it down there I've been skiing there and you know to the the falls and all kind of stuff it's got a massive Coastline it's got aable land great food great wine space for people to live and yet it's mired in poverty and inflation because of political choices of Keynesian taken to you know another level the her ownest um sort of political culture down there and the people after I don't know 50 or 60 years of this [ __ ] are finally fed up let's try something different and you have President melee down there who basically campaigned on their promise of I'm going to cut down government services close a bunch of Ministries we're going to balance a budget and he's already balanced a budget I think within the first quarter or two of him being there so we'll see how the economy reacts so the people do have an option they can reject what the elites are telling them oh there's only one way to do this which is print money and do c in economics no there's another way which is you earn them you propose a taxes we the people agree to pay these taxes and you the government do what we told you to do build roads build schools healthc care police force blah blah blah and don't do anything else and this other [ __ ] that that you got that the government has tacked on to their responsibilities um and created all these deficits so there is another option but it requires people to understand you know where's a situation there is there isn't just one way to do things there's another way to do things there's a way to run the government like you run your household you make a $100 a month you're only able to spend $100 that's it no nobody runs our household like that though there's something about the the culture that we're in right now because if you look at um debt the government operates on a debt businesses are all in debt uh individuals are all in debt we were at 0% interest rates for so long money seemed free people just like just took on debt Deb Deb debt debt and so it really requires a cultural shift more than anything and I worry that what we're seeing in Argentina is that oh yeah there is a point at which it is so brutally painful that people would rather austerity than then continuing to suffer the way they've been suffering but are we anywhere near that point or maybe a better question can we make the change without needing that amount of suffering no because the loss is there the debt has been taken there's been unproductive activity and this is the global thing right Global debt to GDP is I think 360% for the World Bank or something like that and it's been accelerating over the past two decades right so there is an implicit dead weight loss in the system the question is who Bears the loss now that's whatever government is tackling what does everyone government do they push that loss down onto the people themselves VI an inflation tax but the loss has to be paid it's not like the Argentinian situation is without losses people are going to lose money in austerity right the question is who loses the money so if it's I don't like austerity because deflation destroys the banking system well in a capitalist Society what happens when a bank goes bankrupt the unsecured creditors take over the bank so put the [ __ ] CEOs of City Bank and JP Morgan and Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley on the [ __ ] Street after 2008 and give the bank to the depositors that's how bankrupcy law should work it didn't work in that situation they would rather save the managers of the banks than allow the people who are unsecure creditors of the bank take it over and run it how they think it should be run so I think there is we have we being a lot of capitalistic systems and you know even in China they have these sorts of bankruptcy sort of laws it's just that nobody wants to use them because it's going to disenfranchise the elites we have all the tools available to us we've thought about these things we're just unwilling to use them because of who Bears the pain so that's the situation but I think when more people realize the reason why crypto exists it's crypto is valuable because we're unwilling to take these losses if all of a sudden the United States and China and Europe and Japan said we're going to run balanced budgets we're going to cut out 75% of all these government services I would be thinking harder about whether I want to be on crypto at that point and maybe I should be doing something else because the societal mindset has changed to something more responsible and maybe we're not going to see these massive price gains in crypto because the Fiat debasement part of the equation has ceased okay so if that's the scenario that would cause you to rethink crypto um if all of those governments were hey we're going to be like Argentina we're going to get our stuff together we're going to run a balanced budget how would you respond to that in terms of your investment strategy there's obviously going to be some short-term a lot of short-term pain and then you have to see what is bitcoin or crypto worth really fast will you explain why why will there be short-term pain what happens in a austerity when we're not printing like right now the US government is so in debt that surely if they were to just balance the budget immediately without printing any more money that holders of government treasuries bonds poof they would be gone yeah who owns the bonds rich people at Banks so that's who suffers if who's making all these you know the U the US Treasury spends about a trillion dollars on an annualized basis and interest payments who is getting these interest payments all the [ __ ] I saw at the ski resort who now get five and a half% on on their um their cash and like great I own these treasury bonds getting five and a half percent I've got a good Capital base I'm going to go enjoy the world right it's all the rich people who own these Financial assets they're now worth a lot less in a deflationary environment the primary one being government bonds who now the government to balance a budget and guess what all that debt we're just going to gone I mean we can do it Deb Jubilee it's happened in the past study the Roman Empire and you know Greek Solon and certain people like it's a feature of the society where a leader comes and says this is not a good idea for the rich to be rentiers on the entire productive capacity of society let's destroy that asset that they have and requal system we forget that this happens but it has happened in the past and so if we did something akin to a debt Jubilee who loses rich people and then at some point if the government does float another bond with aorn more balanced budget then oh that might be a good investment at a very high rate of return is that better than owning something that has made its gains in Fiat terms I'm not saying that the Bitcoin network is not valuable I separate Bitcoin into technology plus liquidity but if you remove the liquidity piece what's the technology worth I don't know it's worth a lot for sure but removing that liquidity piece from the equation for crypto probably means that it corrects quite substantially and you want to own other types of Assets Now that you know we have the society is decided that we're going to run our public affairs in a different manner all right really fast when you say liquidity are you talking trading volume just the amount of back and forth credit money credit Fiat money in so sorry you said uh Bitcoin is the technology plus liquidity so you mean if nobody's manipulating Fiat and printing printing printing then you take a fundamentally different uh calculation on the value of Bitcoin correct interesting liquidity is one of those words that I've long been like okay I think I know what people mean by this uh but clearly not so when you say liquidity you mean printing yes I mean how much credit money has been created by the government in the banking system and obviously the more Fiat that's around scarce assets finite assets like Bitcoin go up in Fiat terms but that's just a denominator issue it's not anything the value of Bitcoin itself as a network of peer-to-peer decentralized electronic money again that has a value what is that value I think it's very valuable is it I don't know what's the Bitcoin bark up now like two trillion or whatever it is is it that so if we removed all the money printing we said you know US dollar the end the Yuan you know the euro is now sort of very stable currencies not going to go up or down much in terms of their supply do I want to own crypto anymore maybe not at this price maybe there's something else I'd rather own maybe I want to own a power plant in a new productive country where the people feel happy and engaged and want to do productive things maybe I want to own something different so that's that's just the mental you know construct that I'm operating under because the system will change we as you said there is this anger we have Global conflicts spreading up around the world we are not going to be in this Keynesian system in the next 40 or 50 years there will be a different system I don't know what it is it could be that the people all wake up and they say this is not for me we're going to create a more Equitable system or they create something even more [ __ ] up than the one we're in today I don't know but we're just going to change okay uh a couple questions one did Argentina default on their debts they have defaulted multiple times on on their peso dollar like you could probably write a whole university thesis on the history of Argentinian mon monetary policy I mean specifically since melee took office is that part of his strategy like hey debt Jubilee I'm not sure okay I'd be very curious to know that um so okay one possible way for this to end is you have an Argentinian solution uh the country wakes up they realize hey I'm not willing to suffer like this anymore it's a bunch of Rich [ __ ] that are controlling the place we have all these um programs to take care of people but we don't actually have the money and so we've inflated our currency into meaninglessness um this is dumb so let's elect somebody let's take our lumps austerity measures the system's not really working anyway so I imagine to some extent that probably even the wealthy feel like they're on such unstable ground they've probably long ago fled to dollars or something like that anyway if they have the wherewithal to do it uh we elect this guy he comes in literally with a chainsaw for people that haven't seen the footage it is hilarious uh and he just cuts Cuts Cuts removing entire um portions of the government entire departments uh okay so that's one way to do it um the other way to do it is war why does this why does the debt inflation through money printing why does that lead to this changing dynamic between countries what I I can't mentally track I get it I've seen it I know the data but I don't understand why that happens so when you're printing money you're inducing economic activity that's unnatural so so you're producing stuff that you don't you can't sell so what is you know what are most wars about it's I have all this excess production I have people that need to work because that's how I stay in power because they had job and money and whatever they have they're producing all this stuff I need someone to sell it to so if you want to think back to sort of World War I World War II you had the major Colonial Powers each had their own home Market us has you know Central and South America Britain had the Commonwealth um French had the West Indies and sort of parts of Africa and Germany was like Hey I'm a I'm a white Imperial power I deserve I deserve some colonies too rather than going into Africa my Colony should be Russia we read what Hitler wrote he's writing about taking the Russian land and creating space for the Russian people for the for the German people that's why he did the dumb thing of attacking Russia during the winter didn't learn his lesson from Napoleon um the Japanese wanted their colon they thought they were a powerful colonizer as well and China specifically Manchuria would be their sphere of colonial projection and their Market would be southeast Asia and as you know the Western Allied Powers challenged that assertion that Germany and Japan could have these Colonial spheres of trading influence because they also had overproduction as well remember coming out of the Great Depression what was the problem too much production nowhere to put it deflation of assets everybody produced too much [ __ ] they needed to sell it somewhere so that was a Genesis of all these of the world wars now what do we have today China has exhausted its ability to build roads pump a property bubble now they're saying we need to we need to manufacture more stuff well so does America they need to manufacture more stuff so does Europe they did a manufacturing more stuff why is Europe all pissed off at China right now because China's the largest the auto exporter in the world surpassing Germany and Japan and they're like oh [ __ ] there goes one the one industry where we were kicking ass which was high-end luxury cars and your German and French Vehicles China's beating us at this like hand over hand over foot so everybody's producing stuff because they're they're just printing money say go to work make stuff and then it's like okay where do we sell it oh we need to sell our Goods in China chin need to sell their goods in America well nobody wants to open up their Turf to others because they need to sell stuff not to buy other and so that's why when you print this money and you have all this uneconomic activity happening the drive to sell your goods in other markets is what go is what prepares the road to war oh you're not going to let me sell this particular type of product in you know this country well [ __ ] you we're going to war and I'm going to make sure that you can't sell your stuff into into my turf and that is what we're gearing up towards as all the major economic blocks like okay we need to keep people in their job jobs so we're going to print the money they're going to make stuff and now where do we sell it the over the last you know 40 to 50 years the financial ecosystem um has been predicated on a scenario where there's never been a situation where long end so let's call it 10 or 30e bond yields in the US um rise so they go up but they go up faster than in shortterm yields it's called that's never happened for a sustained period of time no over the last 40 50 years it's called a bear steepener right so if I'm a bank I'm an insurance company I'm a pension company and I'm going to model what I think the future's going to look like I'm going to model the way the future's looked for the past 30 40 years which is every time the there's an issue and uh yields go up the government comes in and prints money and squashes it B down they squash the volatility down in the markets because they want to save the banking they don't want anything uh anything to blow up but now because we're in a situation at least in the US Treasury Market where the US government is the issuing the most amount of debt ever right Federal deficits like seven or eight% of of GDP it's as if we're in a war this is you know the largest longest sustained sort of deficit since World War II but we're not in a war you know at least not um an over one uh you have 7 point I think $7.75 trillion worth of debt must be rolled over by 2026 massive amount of debt that's just on the US side so who's going to buy it right the the traditional buyers were one China Japan right China Japan are not buying any more us treasuries China because it doesn't want to become more tether to the dollar from a geopolitical safety issue um Japan because it's also facing an issue in their bond market where their currency is getting trash because they are also trying to save their bond market Japan thankfully to themselves have saved a lot of money over the last 30 40 years and so they're now starting to draw down on that money they're not buying new treasuries they're starting to sell treasuries China is starting to not buy new more treasuries they're starting to sell treasuries and you can look at the official data from the US Treasury you can see the the balance of treasuries owned by China and Japan are declining on the the oil exporter side right talking about OPEC you know Russia is a big member of OPEC Russia is obviously not buying any more treasuries they just and them from the the Western Financial system um Saudi Arabia is not increasing its treasury position it's also decreasing so the oil exporting Nations who previously would earn dollars internationally and park those dollars in the US banking system and buy treasuries they're no longer buying treasuries the US banking system the US banking system is functionally insolvent because The Regulators made the rules in such a way that it was profitable from an accounting perspective not an economic perspective um to essentially take in deposits and Buy Low yielding treasuries and they could do it with almost infinite leverage and a few basis points difference in the in the change in the price and everybody make a lot of money and everybody gets a big bonus right so the banks collectively bought all these treasuries in 2021 and obviously the prices went down a lot since then and that's why we have the the regional banking crisis so at a structural level the US Bing system cannot buy more debt because it can't afford to because it's function ins solvent and so and and you know that leaves the Federal Reserve but the Federal Reserve has committed to doing quantitative tightening which means it's letting the treasuries roll off of its balance sheet it's not accumulating more treasuries so the treasury has to issue all this new debt it has to roll over all this new debt but the major buyers of this stuff for all their own you know disperate reasons cannot purchase it and so what we're seeing in the markets is relationships that held clad are breaking down if you take a look at the the 10-year US Treasury versus gold you would think as yields are rising and US Treasury Market that gold would be getting clobbered that's how it's worked um in in modern Financial history because if the interest rate is high money says I want to own that I want to own the 4 and a half% treasury versus owning gold which pays me nothing but nowadays Gold's holding firm it's not like Rising crazy in a crazy fashion but it's not getting clobbered either as US Treasury uh 10e yields are at you know was 4 434 basis points last time I checked um so hold on that that makes a prediction uh at least as my mind grasps it that people think that the bank is going to default because uh sorry the government's going to default because if you're getting whatever risk-free money of it's right now it's like something like 5% uh if you can have risk-free money at 5% and people are not fleeing gold to get in into that risk-free money at 5% that says to my limited mind that the market no longer believes that it's risk-free is that an accurate uh assumption the market US debt is risk-free in a US dollar perspective on a nominal basis why would people stay in Gold because they say I'm not getting paid enough right um now I I use a term of real yield and if you ask an economist you'll get a different answer depending on who you ask my definition of the real yield is I take the government bond yield and I subtract nominal GDP right so if I'm lending money to the government from a philosophical standpoint I should receive at least the yield of the growth of the economy so if the economy is growing at 10% I should get paid 10% too because I'm contributing to that right I'm lending to the government the government is doing its thing you know and the economy is growing I should get paid the same amount now from the government's perspective you're like hold on I can make a profit if I can somehow engineer the economy to grow at 10% but I only pay you 5% that's a negative yield I I the government and making a profit or conversely if the yield is 10% and the economy is growing at 5% then me the bond holder is earning a profit but right now the economy in the US if you take a look at the latest um Atlanta fed GDP nowcast and they have a real- Time guesstimate on with GDP is running nominal GDP this quarter is running around 9% the 10year yield is about 4.34% so I as a bond holder I'm getting short changed now people are starting to realize like hold on the US economy on paper is growing like Gang Busters I should be getting paid more money if I'm not going to get paid more money then I'm not going to own these bonds because I can own something else that's going to give me a better return whether that's stocks gold crypto whatever right just to just to take a non-controversial one would gold ever outperform that number in terms of the the yield yeah because the way you're explaining it sounds like people are cutting their nose off to spite their face like if you're going to get 5% risk-free with a treasury and you're going to get next to nothing with gold then why on Earth would you even if you could get 10% even if you have a more moral just you have moral outrage at the government for keeping half of that yield for themselves which I admit if you loan the money to the government it's pretty fishy that they would keep that for themselves but if you're getting a better yield then you would get from gold what on Earth are people doing um just saying ah I'd rather get nothing because I'm angry I don't understand so you know most people who own bonds that hold them the bond is a price right so as the yields rise the bond price goes down um so as yields go from 5% to let's say 10% so the fact just keeps raising rates right as a hold over the bond you've lost money because the yields are they're Rising the bond price goes down right so as yields rise I lose money because I've locked in the lower rate and it's going higher the bond price goes down um versus gold which you know could go up right or just could stay flat at the end of the day and I'm I'm fine so if you take a look at returns of 10year bonds starting in two end of 2021 when the FED started raising rates you've gotten absolutely killed it's been the worst bond be markets in hundreds of years right so owning bonds has been a terrible terrible investment over the last two years because inflation is going up and the bond market is saying actually I demand more yield and the g keeps going higher and higher and higher and higher to attract more and more buyers now if the US government was perfectly willing to put the 10-year treasury yield up at 10% they'd have a flood of money into the market that's awesome I'm getting paid the same growth as the US economy but right now I'm not because the government can't afford it right now the treasury is already spending something like 34% of um the budgets like interest payments on an annual bas4 34% yes so it's a$1 trillion dollar annualized right now is the interest expense as of uh second quarter the last time the Tre publes statistic so they're issuing more debt and they're paying more money in the debt and that number is just going like that um in terms of the interest expense handed out to people who own own bonds right but on the long end and this is how bonds work the the longer the maturity the more risk more sensitive you are to interest rates especially if the bond the yield starts at a low level going from 1% to 5% on a 10year treasury absolutely destroys you as a long Bond holder which is why a lot of these bond funds have done terribly well have done terribly over the last few years because of how Bond math works and it's it's a nonlinear change when you raise interest rates and how the bond price performs gold is pretty much held constant um over that time you Haven made money haven't lost money but if you were holding a long Bond at 1 2% and now it's at five you've gotten crushed and that's exactly what happened with the banking system you know svb First Republic uh silvergate signature you you know um this year they've gotten crushed on Long Long bond trading okay I want to walk people through that uh so I when it comes to math I have a very simple mind you're going to correct me where I go wrong but I think people at home some of them are going to benefit from what I have struggled over the last year or so to put together in my mind again you're gonna when I go wrong you need to jump in and and let people know uh but here is how I understand bonds if you hold a bond to maturity you're not going to lose your principal so what you're losing is potential earnings so you would not be able to sell that Bond so uh for those keeping score it goes like this you buy a bond that bond has a a a interest payment and that interest payment let's say is 2% and if you buy that bond for 10 years to get the 2% and a year later a new Bond comes out for 10 years that pays 5% now if you try to sell that bond in the secondary Market are going to go why on Earth would I buy that when I can for the same price I can get a better yield and so you have sort of lost money in that you can't sell it before the mature date you are now going to have to hold it all 10 years in order to get all of your money back but if you hold it for all 10 years you will get your 2% and you will get your uh money back assuming that this is a Government Bond and they don't default so that I I want to make sure people understand the difference between you're losing potential Revenue because if you didn't have your money tied up in a 10-year bond and you could now put it into that other 10-year bond that's earning 5% obviously you'd be better off but you don't lose your money unless you need to sell now that brings us and you will notice he has not interrupted me so I'll assume that's well I'll give it even more even closer to home example people who have a mortgage on a house right I think this is even more understandable like everybody rush should bought houses in 2020 2021 and the old olds I know mortgage 30 your mortgage rates in the US are around three three and a half% and now there's another job another location maybe you're living in a high tax state you want to move to a low tax state right and you need to buy another house same value of the house that the price of the house is the same but you need to get a new mortgage now the mortgage rates are 7 8% and you're like holy [ __ ] I can't afford this house anymore because my this mortgage this this bond that I have at 3% is more valuable than the bond of the mortgage at 78% therefore I can't find another loan that I can service with my income because of the change in interest rates and so that's I think a even more hits home example the majority of the public who own the house or an apartment or whatever it's oh I had a mortgage at 3% I can't and the same value of the house I cannot afford that house in another location because I'd have to get a new mortgage at 78% that is Bond math that's the exact and you can put the same thing for you know treasuries mortgage is a bit more complicated but at a high level that that's that's exactly the phenomenon describing now the mortgage though would be completely inverse right so on a mortgage I want my rate going down on a bond I want my rate going up yeah makes sense um okay so now let's take that so we understand that I buy a a longterm Bond and back in 21 when all the banks gobbled up all this US debt they had to go along to get a return which a bank is incentivized to do so they're going to take the deposits that they're getting everybody's getting stimulus checks everybody's depositing into a bank the bank's like amazing I'm going to invest the first of all the FED is like we're not going to raise rates oh my God it's going to be like this basically forever and so they buy all these long-term Bonds on the word of the FED that they're not going to be raising rates so they think okay well if rates aren't going to go up then I don't have to worry about the value of this going down this will get me a higher yield by me taking a longer term which uh we need to get back to because you were talking about how it's very atypical for shortterm to raise faster than longterm so that's a sign that something weird is happening but in 21 that hadn't happened yet so a longterm was the way to get the extra interest payment so the banks gobble up these long-term uh treasuries so they're buying debt I'll add one little caveat here is you can actually hedge this stuff so it's not as if there isn't instruments to say like okay I bought a bond at 2 3% I'm worried about a future where the FED raises rates let me go out in the market and hedge that the banking system could have easily hedged a lot of this risk and some banks did um a lot of banks didn't but that comes at a cost so I can either have a higher bonus or a lower bonus the FED says don't don't worry I got this know inflation is transitory never raising rates you know we we never going above 2% inflation blah blah blah why would I go out and hedge the long end rates why would I go out in hedge rates going up and reduce my bonus so I'll stop there dude that's horrifying if that and look I'm sure it did I don't want to play naive uh but that's horrible okay so if that's right then to get their bigger bonus they buy these longer term uh treasuries they lock themselves in now the FED does raise the interest rate now that Bond they can't sell it early and therefore they're losing that potential income wouldn't necessarily be a problem except for the fact that people begin to realize hold on a second now the risk-free rate of a US Treasury that I can get myself is 5% so I don't want to leave it in the bank where they're paying me next to nothing I want to go get my 5% risk-free with the government so hey svb I will take my money thank you very much and now svb has to cover that so that they can give you the money back and now they're forced to sell these long bonds at a loss and all hell breaks loose yep that's exact exctly it the US government bankrupted the banking system essentially that that is brutal when said that plainly okay so now my question is they create the uh I just had it the btfp bank term funding program which basically says hey everybody don't worry your deposits are safe uh but the problem is that puts them on the hook for up to $4.4 trillion doar that they would have to print their way out of so do we still have a banking crisis or do we only have a looming potential inflation crisis there is a political Choice there there you know either as people say again I don't I haven't looked at the deposit rates yet but if you are a non- too big detailed bank there's eight of them um it's very hard to attract deposits and it's very hard for you to raise your deposit rate because again you have this this portfolio of stuff and your your deposits are not guaranteed so if I'm a JP Morgan a City Bank or Wells Fargo I forgot the other ones the big Banks they have an unlimited deposit guarantee now they have to pay a bunch of other charges for that but if I'm a deposit in those Banks I know I'm there's no question the politicians have told me I will get 100% of my money back no limit if I'm not in one of those Banks I have to think to myself okay is this Bank going to get saved is this going to be the Leman brothers or is this going to be the Goldman Sachs which one's which one is going to be right they let Leman fail they didn't let Goldman fail right and so it's the thought and so we like well why even take the risk get me the [ __ ] out of here I'm giving my money to Jamie Diamond right and so that's the issue people are fleeing because number one the political Choice has been we are not going to extend a blanket guarantee to all these other smaller Banks because of moral hazard and all these different things we're only going to to these Banks over here so then the rational response of the public is well I don't want to be in that bank I don't want to have to take the risk that they decide that this is the bank they're going to believe in capitalism on I'm GNA go over here let me go to socialism I get my money back um and so I think that's driving part of it and then the other thing is the rates are still going up right five and a half percent you know maybe the FED raises a couple more times it we'll be 6% I can literally two clicks go online go to my money market account deposit money with the government essentially and get more money than my bank can mathematically pay me so yes there's a banking crisis we it was smoothed out a bit with the bank term funding program but it's not as if people have stopped noticing that in less than five minutes they can you know go from 0% to 6% interest income that didn't stop so the bigy crisis is still there the acute political choice that the regulators and the government is going to have to make is still there there is still looming who is going to pay for these losses on the bond portfolios of all these Banks I don't know what they're going to decide but I think they're going to decide to print the money and make sure that the electric gets their deposit back and nominal dollar terms so that's just my my opinion so the bank term funding program does not cover Regional Banks I thought it did no no it covers it covers banks that have um Alle Securities so that essentially means US Treasury bonds and mortgage back mortgage back Securities now the big thing that a lot of people are now focusing on is a commercial real estate right that's not included so it's not as if I lent money to some real estate developer in some Market who's going to build Office Buildings I can't take that loan right now and give it to the fed and get back um 100% of my money back in in dollars right I can take a treasury I can take a mortgage back security I can swap that for dollars I can't swap commercial real estate which is a problem because small Regional Banks were the engine of commercial real estate lending boom over the last you know decades whatever you want to call it so now as we're changing the way we work and you know two to three days work from home for a lot of folks these Office Buildings are becoming kind of irrelevant and the market has frozen so now it's a question of okay what when deals get done how big is the price decline going to be and then Are banks going to have to write down this this section of their balance sheet and oh [ __ ] they're in solvent again or at least we know they're in solvent again or what's the FED going to do are they going to expand the btfp to include commercial real estate loans because this was you know this is the thing that's going down in price or they can expand it to auto loans or are they going to expand it to you know personal loans like all these things that the banks have been lending out where the ability to pay or the asset value is declining that aren't US Treasury bonds and mortgage back securities is the btfp going to be expanded to cover those because if those go down in price the banking system still insolve them right so yes they've solved one portion of the market the one they really really care about which is mortgage back Securities they want Americans to own a house and us treasuries they want Americans to invest in the government now it's all this other stuff they would rather not have to bail it out but again the banking system is choking on all this stuff and they're going to have to make the political choice at some point either they're going to let the non-t Bic to fill Banks actually fail and a lot of you know Americans with small deposits not get their money back or they're going to come in and save the day and bail everybody out and print more dollars okay I think this is the part uh in our program where we point out exactly what inflation is when it was first described to me as an invisible tax I was like it didn't make sense to me and now understanding it better I realize that what you're doing is you're saying okay um we're going to make everybody's money worth a little bit less so by making more of it then the value of any $1 just reduces a little bit and so it becomes a way to spread the taxation across everybody um so the real question the government is asking is okay this Bank whatever they did something that isn't uh well so we already know that mortgage back Securities uh and Treasury those are going to be one for one but if they have something other than that they're asking the question do we want everybody to have to cover this thing that didn't end up working out this investment that didn't work out or are we just going to let them roll over and die um as you look at that and when you think about this three to six month big disturbance is that the thing that you think happens that we get some something triggers a run on these small Banks could be commercial real estate starts uh something kicks off and it starts going down or are there other things on your bingo card other than the regional bank failures I mean usually it's the problems are known it's a question of whether or not we're focusing on and we being the market right so the market knows the commercial real estate's a problem but we haven't really seen a big price markdown because no one wants to trade the the sellers don't want to realize a loss and then have to mark the rest of their portfolio down and thus being solvent and the buyers don't want to buy at this price because they know it's too high so nobody's Trading right so it's that calm situation where okay well the price is still where it was you know 12 months ago but there's no transactions right so once there's a few transactions when people have to sell for whatever reason we don't know what that that it's going to be then we're going to go then it's the fiduciary responsibility is okay well there are these transactions in the market and I now need to mark down my portfolio report to my Regulators oh [ __ ] my Capital buffer is declined therefore I'm insolvent and what usually happens is you know because of the politics they'll let somebody fail someone's gonna there's going to be at least one failure and then the Market's gonna [ __ ] throw a fit um shit's goingon to be trading all sorts of [ __ ] up ways and then you know on one weekend they're like okay we can't let the next one fail right they let uh uh silvergate fail in in March of of this year but they didn't let svb and by fa I mean silvergate went bankrupt and the the depositors are not guaranteed to get their money back by the the um Federal Deposit Insurance Company FDIC whereas with SCB and signature and First Republic they were bailed out they being the depositors were bailed out now obviously the bank management was replaced and Equity holders lost money but the the depositors were were bailed out so usually one person fails there was a Leman there was a bearer before there was Goldman Morgan Stanley everybody else City G so they'll probably let somebody fail first first because the politics demand it once the fear of um looing collapse is instilled in in The Regulators they're then going to say we have to print the money because the system is going to fail what that's going to be I don't know I just see that for whatever reason financial crisis happen in the fall and in you know the winter in the northern hemispheric perspective and so we haven't solved any of these problems they're only getting worse um they're getting exponentially worse and the countries that would usually bail out the American Financial system by buying assets for their own reasons can't do so and so as we progress further into this season where traditionally crisis happens there's going to be something I don't know what it's going to be that's just my my my base case and I want to prepare myself and make sure that I'm able to make money in uh in a situation where um she gets all [ __ ] up yeah okay I didn't know that there's a preponderance of problem s in the fall and winter is that the obvious guess for somebody that's never heard that before would be it has something to do with Energy prices as people have to crank up their usually so in the past it was agricultural um issues right so um the farmers uh the credit tightens in certain parts of the Year depending on when um the farmers need credit to you know buy more equipment to do the winter planting right they receive a bunch of money now they need to to draw down on credit and so that's why you get the spikes in in uh in credit as we move through the agricultural cycle and that's part of the reason why you have um different federal reserve banks in different districts is to try to smooth out that um the demand and supply of credit between the banks in the East and the the agricultural regions in sort of the center of uh center of the country um and you know every other country is kind of the same right farmers are always in debt and they're always Bor Bing money and then receiving lots of money depending on on how the Harvest goes and I think that's part of the reason why we usually experience crisis in harvest season and then winter planting now you said the problem is usually known but it's a question of whether the Market's paying attention to it or not what are some of the problems that you're already aware of whether the markets focus on them or not that could be those um early dominoes that fall so we already know that the US banking system is insolvent from us perspective um we already know that the the major buyers of us treasury debt are not buying and the treasury needs to issue a lot of it that's known um we already know that commercial real estate in the US is a problem it's just that nobody's trading right now because of what I just described you know globally we already know that um China has this massive real estate issue and is deleveraging which means that China cannot contribute to Global growth in the ways that it used to meaning um doing massive government stimulus and essentially buying stuff from the rest of the world to build up their country right China's been P the economic Powerhouse of global growth which leads into the US and European economies you know since the early 90s they they have lost their capacity to stimulate in the ways that they are used to um Japan has is a problem either they're going to save their government bond market or they're going to save their currency Japan holds is one of the richest countries from an asset perspective on their balance sheet are they going to sell down their treasuries their you know fancy us real estate um their Equity positions to essentially help fund the um uh the ability for their Central Bank to manage uh the depreciation of their currency so these are all known things there's nothing hiding which one is the one that causes the spark for everyone to start focusing on freaking out I don't know I think the train wreck will happen so slowly that it might be more imperceptible than we think how long can we print money before that bad thing happens in the bond market and I'll set the table with Japan as far as I know they print money like fiends um is there an obvious breaking point or are we like at the 10% of what we can print Mark 90% of what what we can print so let's use two countries and the big narrative and this is sort of the Keynesian monetary a modern monetary Theory mmt crowd is the government there's infinite capacity for the a federal government to have debt and the first example they look at Japan they have a I don't know what the debt to GDP of at the government level is like 300% or something and look this is perfectly fine you go to Japan everyone's nice food's great trains run on time super safe blah blah blah what they don't understand is what Japan actually did there's a great report by deuts bank and I forgot what it is and it's the label is um Japan the best C the biggest Cary Trade ever run so everyone always looks at the the central government's debt to GDP and they say oh it's ridiculous they forget that you know they think Japan if you ever been to Japan and done any business there you'll realize that Japan is a socialist country with hoisted with capitalism was hoisted on it they're they're very collectivist culture and I'm not saying that in a negative way that's just how they are so you have to combine things that you otherwise wouldn't believe as one into one to get the real Financial picture of Japan so you have to look at okay yes you have government debt then you have the corporate and private sector of Japan the people of Japan they own something like3 trillion us worth of assets around the world World Japan is probably the richest country in the world on sort of an aggregate basis because what happened after the war the US made Japan a colony for a bit lent them a bunch of money helped them get off their feet and said we're going to give you access to our Market please sell us [ __ ] the Japanese said great we're going to essentially subsume the individual and promote the collective so everyone we're going to financially repress you but we're going to make really really good stuff you're going to have a job for Life we'll pay for you year Education Health Care cheap Transportation good food work really hard so that these major companies can sell great stuff to America and that's what Japan did they started with America then it went to Europe then it went to China and Southeast Asia they are the largest holder of us treasuries which is just the savings of the nation plus they own in total about3 trillion dollars of just assets mainly in United States but around the world with all their savings so if you add that back to their debt and then you add back the private Savings of people which is estimated of like5 trillion dollar of just money and just sitting in bank accounts of the Japanese people because they haven't spent anything for the past 30 [ __ ] years because of the deflation that they've been having you get a much different picture you get a DE to GDP of around like a 100% something much different so Japan can print all this money because it owns the [ __ ] world they're not that broke and so people say oh Japan just print a bunch of money it's okay okay it's okay because they were extremely productive they had a captive Market in that the richest country in the world from a GDP perspective America they could freely sell anything they wanted into America and that's how they got so wealthy so that's a Japan example on the why it doesn't really work then you get to China China says we're completely State socialist again not saying that in in a bad way the central government owns essentially all the most productive companies and we are going to debt Finance our way out of the poverty of the you know 1949 to 1980s right massive transformation in the society and there wasn't an infrastructure project that China didn't love and they they've run up with something like a 300% debt to GDP they built all this stuff now if you believe that debt you can print as much debt as you want then why isn't China responding to this property bubble by printing as much money as they can and just doing the same thing they did for the past 20 years because they've reached the capacity of the amount of debt they know that the more debt I spend I produce no value and I just make the problem bigger I create more angst amongst the PO population I create more desire for people not to have children I created a declining population because people you know cannot make ends meet because I've just overproduced and there's just not enough real return there so there is an internal capacity so there China and Japan are probably the two examples that prove the point that I'm trying to make which is there is a capacity limit for debt it's not some number that we know once you go higher than this that things you know automatically happen um there's a paper by Ken Ken rogoff I forgot what it is and he did a study and basically the the the study was that once you get above about 130% debt to GDP on a government level then you're almost you're assume to have a financial crisis sometime in the near future now again you can't put a time frame on it the Us is around 130 140% so it's on that path to doing so does it have capacity to load itself up with a lot more debt absolutely China's at 300% GDP right so you can you can go that far or even farther maybe but again then you start to have the decay in society you get to have you get to have this moral angst that is amongst the population who feel it they can't put their finger on why they don't feel confident or why they feel angry but the reason is that the government has again taking away their dignity by [ __ ] up the money monetary Supply so again I don't know what that number is we're in the territory where something could happen and so my thought is as an investor I want to be long that volatility by being long a put option on The Sovereign bond market which is crypto I don't know when it's going to happen but it's going to happen if they continue doing the these same same things so want I buy something where I have insane upside if it [ __ ] up and what's my downside it's a super liquid asset as soon as if it's not working then I sell a bit of it whatever so I have an asymmetric return debt the debt flywheel uh how is it possible given our need to at a minimum make interest payments that we aren't already in trouble so I think right now our interest payments are already our third biggest line item it's more than our National Defense we're adding a trillion dollars to our debt every roughly 100 days that will compound so what takes 100 days now will be 95 and then 90 and then 80 and then 60 uh I don't understand how we're not at the end what what am I missing because the money because there's so much money trapped in the trefi Western Financial system it's there to be inflated it's there to be taxed every dollar you have in your retirement account every dollar you have in the in your trei big account every stock that you hold that is required to trade on the you know the clearing functions of the US or the European governments is right to get taken by government via an inflation tax so that's how they're able to do it because this capital is sitting around and not doing anything the Pension funds are forced to own government bonds the banks are almost forced to take their excess reserves and buy government bonds and so that's how they're able to keep the game going because there's all this Capital that's sitting around that they can inflate away now that's why crypto is such a fundamental problem because it's an Escape valve it's outside the system I take my Fe out I sell it and now I buy Bitcoin can't take it away from me you don't even know I have it and so that's why the ETF is such a key component which is okay recognize that we have a problem we're not going to change our spending we don't want to outright ban the thing okay now it's time to allow these fund managers to ingest this Fiat into a derivative but keep the Bitcoin within the system you know so that is why you can afford to do this and of course the US is a reserve currency issuer largest military in the world again you have the ability as the the the Empire to to do this a lot longer than other countries can now to the extent that other countries stop saying I'm willing to sell you oil or food or whatever in dollars then the ability to keep this game going uh the time frame diminishes yeah what do you think about the Petro dollar being used to to um have at least a response to our financial Warfare which may be a little unfair but when we for people that haven't thought through this yet when we inflate the currency that spreads it to people like Japan that own trillions of dollars in bonds um so we're we're exporting the inflation tax do you see people weaponizing that do you think cuz I've heard people say oh my God dollarization is imminent and I've heard other people say get out of here there's literally nothing else um so people would flee the dollar to what so I think that they're get missing the point so dollarization started in 2008 when the US authorities decided that they're going to save the banking system by this massive uh money Printing and if you look at the charts and you take a look at U amount of gold that foreign central banks started buying with ner was in 2008 now it's ticking up similarly for the the effect of foreign central banks on buying us treasuries the height 2008 now it's tapering off so detalization is happening slowly at the margins the Roman Empire the the British Empire these Empires didn't fall like overnight it's not like overnight you just stop using these currencies it's a it's it's a slow process it happens at the margins we're already seeing it in 2023 20% % of all oil sales were in a currency other than the US dollar highest ever so the Petro dollar is breaking down slowly at the margin of course the Western world and the US major allies are going to continue using the dollar whether you know China Saudi Arabia whoever uses it or not that's not the question the point of for an investor and trying to save is okay align myself with the trend but don't get blown out of water if it takes a time if dollarization is a trend if the trend is to have a multi-polar situation of currencies being used what do I know that central banks and countries have used in the past to trade between themselves to settle debts and trade flows gold okay that's why I own gold I own gold because I know the countries who are not going to use the dollar to settle their tradeing balances will use gold and are using more gold I want to be alongside that trade okay well what about the people the people don't want to continue to be [ __ ] over by inflation whether they're rich or poor here's a global decentralized digital system that anyone rich or poor can access okay I want that system too another put option on the current you know order of things and again I think people try to get more realistic about it like right or wrong like I believe America's good or bad it doesn't matter all all I'm saying is we're going to change and I want to be long the change and I don't know what it's going to happen in the future I just know what won't be like it was yesterday is there anything right now that is um a plausible replacement for the dollar is it um brics I know is trying to back their currency with gold I think central banks are buying up gold is it a return to a gold standard is there another um governmental currency that has more respectability less inflation I would say the you know in my view the most likely outcome is that countries will continue to use dollar or whatever currency is to trade amongst each other so let's say that I'm you know I have a I have some oil and but I also import food so if I sell more oil than food I need to import I say okay don't pay me the difference in dollars pay me in Gold but I can still invoice my oil in dollars or whatever depending on who's buying it so I I don't think there's going to be one particular Global Reserve currency I think there'll be different economic spheres and the trade between those economic spheres the net of that trade will be settled in Gold interesting okay are you surprised at all that gold does not go up in a similar fashion to bitcoin no because gold is different it's bigger door um it's not digital it's not the new new thing the drivers of gold are very very slow methodical um Central Bank purchases is the crazy volatility in goal will be when let's say that you know the US government wants to help the situation they devalue the dollar and gold and say okay I think the gold on the on the fed's balance sheet is held at $35 an ounce same price that's been since 1970s right they say now our gold on the FED balance sheet is valued at $10,000 an ounce which is basically them devaluing the dollar gold shoots up massively and now all of a sudden a lot of these problems go away because the FED has so much gold they're valuing it at a certain price and now the dollar is seen as a stronger currency so that's a situation that could happen which would massively oneoff increase the price of gold by 3 to 5x and other countries could do the same thing who hold gold at an artificially low value but could revalue it higher on their own balance sheets so that is probably the gold bull market scenario that I'm sort of that's why I own the thing that's the optionality that I'm um playing is a revaluation by central banks to make their currency seem stronger in Gold terms I've never heard that before what what would trigger that oh a war budget crisis I mean the same things that you know the government's done in the past right the when the gold window closed I think FDR um depreciated the dollar in Gold terms by like 80% overnight or whatever it was but obviously you couldn't own gold as a person he did it after that said okay I'm gonna take all your gold now I got all your [ __ ] gold guess what dollar is worth the gold is worth way more dollars now sorry so I think that's a simp Serv of situation that could occur okay let me see if I understand this uh you're I don't understand this why would you want to make gold more expensive what do you plan to do with that buy more gold buy more dollars like what are you doing no you already have a bunch of gold so at least the US is a very Stark example the US Federal Reserve has however many metric tons of gold a lot of it it's held at I think it's $35 an ounce or whatever that price is the very low value gold right now is valued at are they artificially holding that price down they not Hing it saying this is what this is what we value gold at so this is so our balance sheet if you think of like think think about what's a dollar worth it's worth the assets that they hold what's the only real asset that the federal government has in a monetary sense it's gold how much gold do you have what do you value at so us being the reserve currency issuer could say overnight we think that gold is worth $20,000 an ounce and guess what we have I don't know how much they have but and so all of a sudden I was like oh [ __ ] they've just devalued the dollar and gold terms but they own a bunch of gold so now the dollar instead of being a US Treasury backed currency and the US treasuries are trash because of all this spending it's now a gold back currency and guess what they've got a lot of gold and it's worth $20,000 an ounce so hold on hold on sorry sorry sorry I my brain is just too small for this uh but I really want to understand this uh so are you saying that they are reping the dollar to gold in this scenario yes well it wouldn't be a peg per se it's it's what do you think a dollar is worth right if if this if you're if you believe in this dollarization thing and that country is say I don't want to hold the dollar because it's inflating away it has no value it has no assets backing that I don't believe in the US trases well then the federal government and the FED could say oh actually guess what we've got all this gold it used to be worth this now it's worth that this new price we believe gold is worth is massively above the current clearing price of gold for certain individuals we'd be willing to exchange gold for dollars not everyone obviously only certain individuals certain probably Sovereign Nations and all of a sudden the dollar becomes a strong currency again because it why on Earth why on Earth would a government do that like if I saw that you just changed the value of your dollar massively why then would I exchange gold because I'm thinking oo dollars are still great I still want to have dollars and I have gold and so now I'm going to get those dollars like to to me again I'm sure I'm just missing something but to me I would see that as such a wild manipulation of the currency I'd be like I don't want anything to do with a currency that just changed 35 you should old Bitcoin but this is how Fiat currencies have worked in the past and this and this was done in the 19 what's the incentive it is because you have to devalue the currency the US needs a weaker currency a weaker currency helps you sell your export I get our incentive but something is only worth what someone else is willing to pay why is someone else willing to trade their gold for dollars in that scenario obviously someone is or they wouldn't do it well no one no one has to trade anything I'm saying the the government itself says that we believe go is worth this price right now they say it's worth $45 or what $35 whatever it is on their balance sheet now it's worth we will exchange gold at this price way up here and they're able to do that because they own a [ __ ] ton of gold if you didn't own a lot of gold then I would agree with you why would you do that this is more a way to engender a belief that the dollar has a a large gold value well okay here's what we value gold at on our balance sheet and we're able to do this because we're the central bank and you can exchange gold at this price now it's much higher than the price that it is around the world now that only works if you have a lot of gold us has a lot of gold China has a lot of gold Russia has a lot of gold so there's there is a thinking out there that any number one of these countries that have been accumulating a lot of gold could say our currency is very strong guess what we're willing to bid for gold at this high price therefore sell me oil in my currency because you know that you're going to get gold at a very attractive price because this is what it's worth sell me medicine sell me wheat whatever it is so it's a confidence game amongst other issu other trading partners to say my currency is worth a lot of gold because gold is has historically been the real currency of the world not these Fiat things man again so that seems false what you're saying is my gold is worth a lot of currency my currency is worth a tiny bit of gold if my currency used to be um $35 buys you an ounce of gold and now it's ,000 buys you an ounce of gold the gold got expensive the currency devalued in its purchasing power anyway probably tearing their hair out right now say that again but I also but I also have trillions of dollars of debt so now my currency devalued in Gold terms but I owe a fixed amount of debt right so the reason why and another the reason why I devalue your currency is well I own I owe a lot of it I I owe a lot of it and now it's worth less I've decided it's worth less so I can pay you back but you're getting paid back in depreciated dollars now obviously going forward people who trade going forward have a different deal than people who have traded stuff in the past so again yeah I agree with you it's a [ __ ] up way to treat people who invested in and your bonds but again it's another option that you can use as a sovereign country is devaluing your currency and goal terms to pay back an unsustainable debt load if you don't want to outright default by saying I'm just not gonna pay you back instead of saying that you're saying okay I'll devalue in Gold I'm gonna say psych it's worth like on10th of what uh you thought it was worth that's crazy I can't believe that they can do that uh insane okay let's talk about uh all the liabilities since we're on the subject uh do you think that the US so going back to this idea of Argentina comes in they slash spending uh for the US to get back on track they would have to slash spending um Social Security is basically a pyramid scheme um would they be wise to to Lop off Social Security and uh could you see that actually happening with any sort of political plausibility the United States given that boomers are more uh politically active I would say that it would probably be a death sentence for most politicians to try to take away those health benefits now a very skill politician who's able to get a lot more younger people out to vote and explain to them how they've gotten [ __ ] over by the old people in the country if that person's able to do that put in that kind of work then yes I think that you know a Reformation of the United States's healthc care system could be on offer but if if you're not willing to put in that sort of political work to re-energize the younger constituents there's no [ __ ] way he'll be able to do it did you see the video that um Ben Shapiro posted about retirement and Social Security no it's very interesting lighting the uh the internet on fire and he basically said look Social Security is not going to play out the way that you think you're probably not going to be able to reap the benefits um not with people retiring as early as they are you should you know look at pushing retirement back or removing retirement all together um if you look at managing a fiscally responsible country is that an option on the table for you or do you think that there are better ways to get that done absolutely you should remove I I I think these these programs are great for the people you know the Boomers right they're the biggest beneficiaries of of all these you know around the world they sort of like Social Security Programs depending on how you you pay for them and removing them would remove that that dead weight but I think at the other end you also need to sort of Reform like you know Global sick care which is the health industry and the misalign incentives right people shouldn't be dying the way they're dying based on the shitty food that we eat and the overprescribed medicines there shouldn't be and that's why people oh I need to have this health care because everybody gets sick why does everyone get sick because we eat [ __ ] processed food and all this dog [ __ ] that's you know put out to us as healthy there's a reason why everybody spends a majority of their money in the last like two years of their life dying of horrible cancers and heart disease and all this kind of [ __ ] right we're poisoning ourselves every single day with these [ __ ] up food chains so I think it's not just let's remove the retirement benefits and the healthcare as well let's get at the root problem of why do we treat people the way we treat them and the Healthcare Systems around the world let's have a better relationship with food yeah one thing I don't think people really understand is that you can obviously because we print to make all these problems go away but if healthc care costs you know let's say 10x what it needs to cost if people were actually healthy um you are quote unquote bankrupting the country and that you get to a point where there's no way that the productivity uh of the country could possibly match that so you've got the interest payments just absolutely insane you've got sickcare management insane you've got Social Security retirement um all of it becomes really unmanageable I have until recently I had no visceral relationship with how those expenses actually played out in terms of the budget until I started looking at how much the government spends versus the actual GDP of the country that stuff gets very scary and that's why we race towards War we flood into crypto it all comes back there all right then let me ask you where does eth go we've talked about Bitcoin where do you think eth goes from where it's at now oh maybe 340,000 uh whoa that's mosive what what do you think gets us there just the knock on effect of everything that happens to bitcoin has a trickle down to eth trickle down you have you have the um eth ETF possibly the ethereum is the decentralized computer and the decentralized computer has a commodity the eth the currency that pays an intrinsic 4% yield which is the staking yield of it's the only you know crypto asset of that size that has this intrinsic yield and that's going to draw a lot of it's the internet Bond it's the bond of the internet computer and pays you a yield to own it and so I think that's going to be very powerful narrative as people start to think a bit more about what actually what eth actually is and they're going to allocate and say oh well not only do I get sort of this deflationary network value increase and the E the currency I'm also getting paid 4% Yi e where else do I get that sort of return that's great I want to allocate to this and there's all sorts of different interest rate strategies you can do around that but I think that's going to be a big narrative for people who are going to get into eth and understand oh great I get to participate in let's create a new Digital internet on Defi and I get for % yield why do you think that right now eth seems to be more to the upside I don't know if this is true to the dollar but it seems to be more to the upside than Bitcoin so I'll see Bitcoin dip but eth just keep going not that it hasn't had its own dips but um are people pricing in the future in a greater way than they're pricing in the reality of Bitcoin today I don't think so it's a smaller asset right so smaller things move faster just law of large numbers so I'm not really yeah I don't think so so do you think its rate of um rate of increase will speed up if an ETF goes for sure just like Bitcoin just more more assets and you know if people are actually using the ethereum network post the the merge you it becomes the the supply of eth actually declines so there's less eth available the more people use the thing so if we believe in Defi and the network activity grows in defi because more people know about it they want to experiment then not only the the total supply of eth declines and then you have the ETF you know taking eth out of circulation as well so you get sort of a double whammy effect uh on on sort of the price on the upside the narrative that I've been hearing is you're going to get big gains in Bitcoin you're going to get bigger gains in eth and then you're going to get even bigger gains in salana is that just one do you agree with that narrative and two is that just a law of large numbers or is this um people seeking out the highest volatility clearest narrative assets it's oh I guess timing is everything so we think about last cycle so Bitcoin went down something went from 69,000 down to 16,000 right salana went from 250 I think to seven so yes from 7 to 250 is going to be a bigger return from 16,000 to 69,000 right it's just it's the um path dependency of returns and the time in which you get in and out of an asset so you could make much more money in salana or some other much lower market cap shitcoin than you could make in Bitcoin but if your ass doesn't get off the train at the right time you're going to get absolutely wrecked versus Bitcoin yeah you might get wrecked but it won't be as bad as going from 250 to 7 so again it's it's one of those things where yes you can make more money in lower market cap shitcoins but if you don't time it right you're going to lose more on the downside so you have to sort of balance those those two together all right as a Trader you seem very comfortable with what I'll call trading on culture trading on um Trends momentum because when I talk to people about why I'm a Believer in Bitcoin why I'm a believer in ethereum I can say very robustly that I have a thesis around where the world is going and those are going to be long-term adoptions they're not fugazi as you have said about other things including the trafi system um there there's just something really intrinsic about them now there's a flaw in the Bitcoin thing if it can't whether it's ordinals or whatever whether it can't become another thing which it it has that sort of looming Spectre but that narrative digital gold it being the store of value makes sense uh ethereum world's computer it's a bond in the distributed world's computer cool those make sense beyond that when you get into nfts maybe salana although if they can speak to maybe gaming uh web through gaming or something like that then they're there could really be a core thing there um but I have a feeling that's not why you're trading on it that this is really just about H people get hyped about a thing I'm able to read the tea leaves I see what they're getting hyped about I know the signs to get on the train I know the signs to get off the train and I trade on that is that an accurate assessment yes so I believe that I have a at least for the assets that I large in my portfolio I have a fundamental understanding of like what they are what they're not and I can trade on the narrative and know when the narrative gets out of whack with what they fundamentally are then maybe it's time for me to step off versus I don't understand what these things I've never read the white papers for Bitcoin or ethereum or you know reading research from very much smarter individuals on the like technical things that are going on I just know what I read on Twitter your ass is going to get wrecked because you don't even know whether you're believing in something that's true or false at least if I know I'm trading a piece of [ __ ] I know it's a piece of [ __ ] and I'll size my position accordingly that's interesting uh okay so everything is gambling getting in the elevator versus walking up the stairs is a gamble I think that people would do well to conceptualize all of investing to an extent as a gamble the reason that I think that um Bitcoin specifically and crypto in general will be here is I believe that tomorrow is going to be more digital than today I believe that every generation grows up like a fish in water and when you're born and crypto is just a thing and you don't even think about it uh yeah you it would not make sense to you that that is somehow less valuable than uh Fiat money especially when everything you do you buy your skins and video games and to you there those are as valuable as your real clothes and you love them just as much and um so you know when I think about kids uh and v-bucks it's they're just digital natives like through and through so I think for them it will just make all the sense in the world and so once something is digital then why wouldn't you want your money to be digital as well then it becomes a question of control because hey the government will be more than happy to come out with a cbdc uh and the that then collides with freedom so I don't know how humanity is going to answer that question I'll be completely honest when I think about I think people like being taken care of I think there is a Hu like when you read the rhetoric from 1776 like those guys were ready to Die For Freedom we're not there we're not there like right now it is just a different time man and so I think people want the convenience of something digital I think money will be digital I think people will live in digital worlds I think they will buy digital Goods but I don't know where we're going to settle on uh a desire for protection like even myself I it wasn't until um svb looked like it was going to collapse that I finally was like you know I should just get I didn't have any direct exposure to svb um but it it made me just take everything off every exchange uh but then when you look at the realities of cold storing and you realize you have to store them in different places and not at your house and it was like oh God like I just felt so I still feel so paranoid I'm GNA forget where I put something or half of my key which is in you know this place like I forget which one has what oh god like that kind of stuff terrifies me and so what do you think about that do you think that people will truly while they'll Embrace digital money I think most people will agree to that do you think they're going to care enough about money privacy which is something I've heard you talk a lot about with Bitcoin will they care enough to make Bitcoin which maybe's trying to be choked by the government and all that will they do it or will they just take their cbdc so I think most people don't care about privacy and that's I I know this because they have a mobile phone in their pocket a smartphone a smartphones tracking you um we voluntarily have given the most amount of information about ourselves to Facebook Google Alibaba WeChat all these things right because we want Community we want to communicate with each other um we want to look at thirst traps whatever the reason is right um uh we've done this no the government didn't force us to do this these were private companies creating these products right so most people as you said it's just too much to be financially independent to actually be your own financial institution for a lot of people is is just too much and they're going to stay in in this system and I like to say that there's a there's a flood coming this you know inflationary uh maybe pseudo collapse of the Fiat Financial system there's an there's a Noah's got an arc of you know Satoshi on there with Bitcoin unfortunately most people are going to drown because this isn't this isn't for them right and so um when you move it up to the government aspect crypto in itself isn't a problem the problem is that the people own it and it's not the standard individuals and firms that are used to owning the new lovers of Technology ology and that's their issue with it uh and so now we're seeing that this the experiment has worked so far we have however many millions of wallets created we have however many trillions of dollars worth of transaction that have been completed on these systems they work it's more sound than the traditional finances it's faster it's cheaper fine well let's not have a bunch of Muppets running around the world who uh aren't a bunch of old bald dudes sitting in New York London and comp parison whatever uh owning this thing we want to move it back to who should be owning this so we're going to now allow the traditional Financial players to launch things like ETFs right which is a very easy way for everybody to own the financial return of Bitcoin very important I say the financial return not actual Bitcoin as you said I don't want to M private keys I don't want to worry about where I put my wallet I guess want to earn that inflationary protection aspect of Bitcoin but I don't necessarily care to really experience the real Financial Freedom of it of owning my own Financial system in my pocket in my head right so I'll just put some Fiat into the Black Rock ETF the Fidelity ETF or the pick your large asset manager wherever you're from ETF right you don't own Bitcoin you don't you don't care about custody like oh the price goes up and down on the screen I've beat inflation but guess what my money when I want to sell comes right back into right back in the banking system right back ready to be financially repressed to make sure that bonds are purchased by the banking system to keep governments afloat now fine Bitcoin is an open architecture everyone should be able to build whatever Financial products they want the question then becomes and I don't know the answer to this is Will so much value in currency be owned by these centralized asset managers who are essentially arms of the the trafi ecosystem that the underlying fundamentals of what Bitcoin is the Privacy will those be altered will you know a black rock support through maybe ownership and large mining companies different sorts of improvement protocols that detract from the mutability of the money or the censorship resistance or the the decentralization right so while we as Traders re are cheering yes ETF ETF ETF that's going to bring all this money into the system because now people who want to escape inflation understand the the value prop of fixed Supply and all that but just don't want to deal with the the technology aspect of a be a cryptographically bearer asset because C is bad with passwords and whatnot people don't want to deal with that they want to put their money in the ETF and we're yes great more money in the in the system number go up everybody's rich but are we inviting in something that's going to fundamentally change what Bitcoin is because now they're going to have a say through large ownership and Mining pools or they're going to run a bunch of nodes or they're going to have control over the price right it's an open question and this is going to be the real Crucible we're going to have to face as an industry of determining what is bitcoin when now we have trefi who is a stakeholder in this system how do we deal with them how do we maintain this ethos that makes Bitcoin valuable this immutability this money this the hardest ever existed with a system that is basically trying to capture as much capital and sequester it so that I can pay the inflation tax to make sure that the government stay afloat I don't have the answer to that but that is the real you know crucible that we're going to have to face in going forward because as you rightly point out it's just pain in the ass to be your own financial institution it's interesting that one feels easy to me I don't uh I if if the money really stands stands for Freedom then you have to let people do what they're going to do I saw this in web 3 a lot and there was a sense of like uh we the vanguards of web 3 are going to decide who is web 3 enough and uh if you don't pass the purity test then you know we don't want you in here and it's like you're never going to be able to to get something to scale by trying to impose culture top down culture is always and I mean always going to arise from the bottom and you can manipulate it through media and stuff like that but at the end of the day man that what what people internalize is going to become the culture the youth will always get uh whatever culture they decide they want like it it is just an Unstoppable force and yeah to me it's like Satoshi created the thing and then the thing's going to become what the thing becomes and if if there is a way to control it then it will become no better than the thing that it's trying to replace which is already something that's being controlled and the whole point is you think you want to be able to control it because you think you have all the answers and you're going to do everything right and the reality is as soon as somebody can control it then they will control it and use it against you which is the whole point like I mean just to get myself in hot water here when I saw what was going on with the Canadian trucker Convoy I was like yo they are freezing people's assets that donated to a cause like that's crazy I couldn't believe it that that really got me way more interested in having something that I could control now I'm not convinced the government can't um use Force to get what they want at a crypto because at the end of the day look if the government puts a big enough gun in my face here's my crypto so you know I get it it's easier and if I leave before they start breaking out the guns then fair enough but God I don't want to I don't even want to contemplate a world that gnarly yeah I hope it never comes to pass you and me both so I have to ask where do you think Bitcoin is going is this something that you know uh breaks 100,000 is it something that breaks a million is Michael sailor gonna be a hero or the world's biggest L what do you think so my my working model is that you know we're going to continue chopping around 25 20 30,000 this year um as we get to some sort of financial disturbance and people recognize that real rates are negative if you know if Government are growing if the economy is growing at nominal rate of 10% but I'm only getting 5% 6% even though it's High people are on the margin going to start buying other stuff crypto being one of those things so coming into 2024 either we get a financial crisis rates go to zero or we keep raising rates but not as not fast not as fast as governments are spending money because they're just trying to keep people doing things and the rates are negative that we get to crypto around 70,000 uh by the end of 2024 and that's combination of the crypto havening event right um maybe there's going to be you know a few ETFs launched by large asset managers in the US and Europe and China maybe Hong Kong to be specific so we regain the all-time high by end of 2024 and that's when the real fund starts right that's when real bull market starts and so my mental model for where we could go I think we're gonna go somewhere between you know 750,000 to a million dollars in Bitcoin on the upside right and we're going to whatever the level is there's going be a round number everyone be focusing on I guess like Bitcoin hit 69,000 999 didn't hit 70,000 and then it's going to go and just crash you know 75 8 90% whatever it is right doesn't matter but yeah so my upside Target ises so of the 75 750,000 million level 2026 um time frame just because again I believe this is going to be the largest market in financial bull market in financial assets we have ever seen in human history so not only will Bitcoin be at a ridiculous price you know NASDAQ will be at a ridiculous price S&P will be at a ridiculous price you know pick your you know stock indic wherever you're if you're not in one of in the Europe or the us that'll be at a ridiculous price right certain types of property ridiculous prices um so we're going to have a lot of ridiculous prices out there and not just in in crypto yeah that that will be a weird moment and with people thinking that the party is never going to end uh of course it always does um let me ask you so that I can help better understand the sort of way that this all plays out at the global level what what is with Hong Kong and crypto China clamped down really hard it seemed like that was a really bad sign for me I was like whoa this was the thing that I was concerned about that a government would be able to effectively eliminate it from its country uh not that they'd be a one China never eliminated crypto they never eliminated crypto from China tell me more so the the you know if you want to think about from the Chinese government perspective the thing that they most they care most about is social stability right and so as everyone becomes a Speculator because they're desperate right the last thing they want is a bunch of Mom and Pops rolling up uh and gathering in groups with a communal grievance it could be crypto could be anything right we know all this stories you know uh has played out over Chinese history they do not like this and so seeing that you know that could cause disturbance in China and also you have the energy aspect of Bitcoin mining consuming a lot of electricity that could be used to do other things um they basically made it very hard to trade it so the exchanges all left you know Chinese people still own Bitcoin that hasn't changed you can't mine it there's no exchanges fine they can't really acquire it but at the end of the day I think the Chinese government sees that this is a technologically sound thing um and they want more of it in the Chinese diaspora that they can control it doesn't necessarily need to be in a government Coffer but the Chinese government thinks if you are Chinese we own you as a person you are Chinese we are the Chinese government therefore you are our subject no matter where you live uh around the world ethically speaking and so if you think about Hong Kong which is part of China now and always was but now it's very explicitly part of China um but it's has this Western Capital western eastern Capital meeting point if they want to experiment in allowing a more General um ownership of crypto or if they want to allow certain types of Chinese individuals to own crypto crypto through Hong Kong regulated financial institutions which essentially means that they're controlled by the Chinese government in the same way that black rock is controlled by the US government it's no different um then they're going to allow these companies to buy and hold crypto because at the end of the day as long as the crypto is inside of China they believe that they can control it so why not let a part of the country experiment with this thing let people own it let people buy it um by controlling it in in terms of the way firms are able to acquire users and let those users on crypto so that's why there's been licenses issued um the Hong government's very positive on bitcoin the Hong Kong government is part of China therefore they would never do this if it was not blessed by uh blesson Beijing as part of a national prerogative for this particular part of China to be positive on crypto so it's similar sort of situation to how to describe the Black Rock ETF right Larry thinkink and BlackRock having a trillion dollars Bitcoin under its custody is the same thing as you know Bank of China launching an ETF on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange and having a trillion dollars of crypto they're both essentially in the orbit of either the United States or China and that's the goal if this technology is as transformative if it is the hardest money that's ever existed wouldn't you rather your citizens have it rather than someone else's and so as the American political establishment decides what they want to do with crypto and that uncertainty drives companies out of America out to the rest of the world China's already gone through that they've already purged the exchanges you know starting in 2017 and culminating in like you know I think 2020 right now they've gone the other direction okay let's try to control this let's try to permit certain types of ownership through firms that we can control in Hong Kong which is our testbed region for sort of you know Financial Innovation and give the Hong Kong economy something to um draw in to expertise foreign Capital because you know Chinese government believes in technology crypto is a forfoot and financial technology why not bring these smart people here let them experiment and we think we can control what they do right so that's in my opinion what's behind the Hong Kong story we're going to see how that progresses I obviously live in Hong Kong I love Hong Kong um I hope that there is a vibrant cryptocurrency ecosystem there and that people are able to experiment with different things because there is you know a task of government support for the technology we'll see what happens you know at the extreme if you know all of a sudden there's all these firms with you know trillions of dollars with crypto I don't know but at least there are some people who are given the space to at least experiment and try it versus other places in the world where they're being pushed out and shun yeah I'll be very interested to see how it plays out I was super intrigued when China opened that back up in Hong Kong it made me realize okay maybe they're not as negative as I thought they were and you said this is really an element of control uh which does make me super uneasy in terms of uh just governments having more control than I am comfortable with but uh I fully recognize uh that the way that it's looked at and as somebody who lives there you can certainly speak to this better than I can that it's not necessarily one is better than the other they are just different but man from my perspective it just seems better uh to be free but I I won't try to export my values um so one thing that I want to get a better understanding of is um I had Peter Schiff on the show and in the comments because he was like right down my alley in terms of all my fears like he was right there uh everything that if I'm honest he comes very close to articulating exactly what I think is going to happen when I just objectively look at the math of all this uh and then one of the comments in the feed was uh Peter shiff has predicted nine of the last two recessions and uh I had to laugh at that so you know we've the backdrop to our whole conversation has been a sort of mutual acceptance that yeah all hell is probably going to break loose uh that we think we have a pretty good handle on just the physics of the math and that it can't go up forever that you using my analogy you will pull this rubber band back until it snaps uh there's just no way around it what if we're wrong so what if we're wrong well if we're wrong if there is a energy Miracle like we discover some form of energy we instantly commercialize it like think of how long it took for us to get to a car me every household in the US think of how long it took us to Electrify the world even though these Technologies created in the 19th century mid but that already assumes we can't have a soft Landing what if we just they get it right if they get it right then you earn you could you what you earn now right the S&P is up I don't know let's remove the tech stocks right it's up I don't know six seven eight% this year whatever it is right could made the you say you could I could make the same amount I can make the same amount in bonds and in live literally overnight lending to the Federal Reserve zero Financial Risk I get paid five and a half 6% why take the risk if they get it all right great I'm taking I'm getting 2/3 if not 75% of the return of in the US Stocks with taking none of the mark to Market risk so it's actually makes zero sense to own stocks if you believe they're going to get it right because stocks aren't returning enough it's not like the SV is up 25% and cash yield six right so from a risk adjust R risk adjusted perspective if they get everything right then okay maybe the only s you know is an Nvidia fine the rest of the market is dog [ __ ] why even why even why even play the game put your money in a money market fund take your money out of your 0% yielding bank account put it in a money market fund there's just no point to trading stocks if they have it all right what would have to be true for you to say yeah I no longer think there's anything looming on the horizon there's no financial crisis coming they'd have to get I assume the uh debt to GDP down below below 130 I assume they' need to start uh pulling some money out of the uh economy without it causing any sort of secondary knock on effect um what else well so the US government right now is running the The Playbook they should be running right which is nominal GDP is at 9% but the government debt yields four and a half call it right so the government's making money it's if it can continue to keep money in the bond market in the banking system at these rates and at this growth level then the US government at least for them will deleverage themselves over time the problem is that Capital can move so we're making the assumption that Capital doesn't move so if for my for the you know go go luck scenario number one no Capital leaves the long-term bond market when they have a negative real yield right number two there there is a energy Miracle or we decide that nuclear is the next thing and we run out to invest in all sorts of different types of startups to basically miniaturize nuclear reactors such that instead of pumping oil into our car we have a small little U nuclear reactor and that powers our our vehicles or we're going to build all these different power plants like that needs to happen right immediately that those are the things that would say okay maybe I'm wrong and we're going to have sort of an acceleration in energy productivities therefore I should own a company that makes real stuff apart from you know semiconductors otherwise I'm put overnight bonds because at this the second they cut the rates cool I don't care I didn't lose any money I just take my money of the bonds and I go buy stuff right but I'm definitely not gonna own longterm long end bonds that that trade is negative EV negative expected value in my perspective I don't see how they get all these things right before money leaves the system saying [ __ ] this I want 9% not four and a half um so why own the long end just put all your money in short-term bonds if you believe that they are going to get S everything just put your money in short-term bonds and take no risk to hear more about Ray Delio's warning on the upcoming recession which we're almost certainly already in watch the full episode here talk to me about the three forces that you see that are influencing this moment we've got Banks collapsing US dollars under attack uh looming recession what